diff --git a/boards/views/all_threads.py b/boards/views/all_threads.py
--- a/boards/views/all_threads.py
+++ b/boards/views/all_threads.py
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
+import re
+
 from django.core.paginator import EmptyPage
 from django.http import Http404
 from django.shortcuts import render, redirect
@@ -38,6 +40,7 @@ PARAMETER_RSS_URL = 'rss_url'
 TEMPLATE = 'boards/all_threads.html'
 DEFAULT_PAGE = 1
 
+PATTERN_THREAD_NUMBER = re.compile(r'^(\D*)(\d+)(\D*)$')
 
 class AllThreadsView(BaseBoardView, PaginatedMixin, DispatcherMixin):
 
@@ -59,18 +62,8 @@ class AllThreadsView(BaseBoardView, Pagi
         if not form:
             t_from_id = request.GET.get('t_from_id')
             if t_from_id:
-                source_op = Post.objects.get(id=int(t_from_id))
-                tags_str = ' '.join([tag.get_name() for tag in source_op.get_thread().get_tags()])
-                post_link = '[post]{}[/post]'.format(source_op.id)  #FIXME To constants
-                new_title = source_op.get_title() + ' NEW'  # TODO More intelligent name change
-
-                form = ThreadForm(error_class=PlainErrorList,
-                                  initial={
-                                      FORM_TAGS: tags_str,
-                                      'subscribe': subscribe_by_default,
-                                      FORM_TEXT: post_link,
-                                      FORM_TITLE: new_title,
-                                      })
+                form = self.get_rollover_form(request, t_from_id,
+                        subscribe_by_default)
             else:
                 form = ThreadForm(error_class=PlainErrorList,
                                   initial={FORM_TAGS: self.tag_name,
@@ -149,3 +142,29 @@ class AllThreadsView(BaseBoardView, Pagi
         settings_manager = get_settings_manager(request)
         settings_manager.set_setting(SETTING_ONLY_FAVORITES,
                 not settings_manager.get_setting(SETTING_ONLY_FAVORITES, False))
+
+    def get_rollover_form(self, request, t_from_id, subscribe_by_default):
+        """
+        Create a new form template, passing on threads, link to the old thread,
+        and incremeting the thread number in the title if there is any
+        (or adding 2 if there isn't, normally meaning this was the first
+        thread in a series).
+        """
+        source_op = Post.objects.get(id=int(t_from_id))
+        tags_str = ' '.join([tag.get_name() for tag in source_op.get_thread().get_tags()])
+        post_link = '[post]{}[/post]'.format(source_op.id)  #FIXME To constants
+
+        old_title = source_op.get_title()
+        m = PATTERN_THREAD_NUMBER.match(old_title)
+        if m:
+            new_title = m.group(1) + str(int(m.group(2)) + 1) + m.group(3)
+        else:
+            new_title = old_title + ' 2'
+
+        return ThreadForm(error_class=PlainErrorList,
+                initial={
+                    FORM_TAGS: tags_str,
+                    'subscribe': subscribe_by_default,
+                    FORM_TEXT: post_link,
+                    FORM_TITLE: new_title,
+                    })