obsolete: fix relevant-obsmarkers computation on pruned changeset

The markers pruning a node was not directly considered relevant for the pruned
node, only to its parents.

This went unnoticed during obsmarkers exchange because all
ancestors of the pruned node would be included in the computation.
This still affects obsmarkers exchange a bit since "inline" prune markers would
be ignored (see second test case). This went unnoticed, because in such case,
we always push another obsolescence markers for that node.

We add explicit tests covering this case.

(The set of relevant changeset is use in the obsmarkers discovery protocol used
in the evolve experimental extension, the impact will be handled on the
extension side).

mercurial/obsolete.py

@@ -1,1298 +1,1301 b''
 # obsolete.py - obsolete markers handling
 #
 # Copyright 2012 Pierre-Yves David <[e-mail]>
 #                Logilab SA        <[e-mail]>
 #
 # This software may be used and distributed according to the terms of the
 # GNU General Public License version 2 or any later version.
 
 """Obsolete marker handling
 
 An obsolete marker maps an old changeset to a list of new
 changesets. If the list of new changesets is empty, the old changeset
 is said to be "killed". Otherwise, the old changeset is being
 "replaced" by the new changesets.
 
 Obsolete markers can be used to record and distribute changeset graph
 transformations performed by history rewrite operations, and help
 building new tools to reconcile conflicting rewrite actions. To
 facilitate conflict resolution, markers include various annotations
 besides old and news changeset identifiers, such as creation date or
 author name.
 
 The old obsoleted changeset is called a "precursor" and possible
 replacements are called "successors". Markers that used changeset X as
 a precursor are called "successor markers of X" because they hold
 information about the successors of X. Markers that use changeset Y as
 a successors are call "precursor markers of Y" because they hold
 information about the precursors of Y.
 
 Examples:
 
 - When changeset A is replaced by changeset A', one marker is stored:
 
     (A, (A',))
 
 - When changesets A and B are folded into a new changeset C, two markers are
   stored:
 
     (A, (C,)) and (B, (C,))
 
 - When changeset A is simply "pruned" from the graph, a marker is created:
 
     (A, ())
 
 - When changeset A is split into B and C, a single marker is used:
 
     (A, (B, C))
 
   We use a single marker to distinguish the "split" case from the "divergence"
   case. If two independent operations rewrite the same changeset A in to A' and
   A'', we have an error case: divergent rewriting. We can detect it because
   two markers will be created independently:
 
   (A, (B,)) and (A, (C,))
 
 Format
 ------
 
 Markers are stored in an append-only file stored in
 '.hg/store/obsstore'.
 
 The file starts with a version header:
 
 - 1 unsigned byte: version number, starting at zero.
 
 The header is followed by the markers. Marker format depend of the version. See
 comment associated with each format for details.
 
 """
 from __future__ import absolute_import
 
 import errno
 import struct
 
 from .i18n import _
 from . import (
     error,
     node,
     phases,
     policy,
     util,
 )
 
 parsers = policy.importmod(r'parsers')
 
 _pack = struct.pack
 _unpack = struct.unpack
 _calcsize = struct.calcsize
 propertycache = util.propertycache
 
 # the obsolete feature is not mature enough to be enabled by default.
 # you have to rely on third party extension extension to enable this.
 _enabled = False
 
 # Options for obsolescence
 createmarkersopt = 'createmarkers'
 allowunstableopt = 'allowunstable'
 exchangeopt = 'exchange'
 
 def isenabled(repo, option):
     """Returns True if the given repository has the given obsolete option
     enabled.
     """
     result = set(repo.ui.configlist('experimental', 'evolution'))
     if 'all' in result:
         return True
 
     # For migration purposes, temporarily return true if the config hasn't been
     # set but _enabled is true.
     if len(result) == 0 and _enabled:
         return True
 
     # createmarkers must be enabled if other options are enabled
     if ((allowunstableopt in result or exchangeopt in result) and
         not createmarkersopt in result):
         raise error.Abort(_("'createmarkers' obsolete option must be enabled "
                            "if other obsolete options are enabled"))
 
     return option in result
 
 ### obsolescence marker flag
 
 ## bumpedfix flag
 #
 # When a changeset A' succeed to a changeset A which became public, we call A'
 # "bumped" because it's a successors of a public changesets
 #
 # o    A' (bumped)
 # |`:
 # | o  A
 # |/
 # o    Z
 #
 # The way to solve this situation is to create a new changeset Ad as children
 # of A. This changeset have the same content than A'. So the diff from A to A'
 # is the same than the diff from A to Ad. Ad is marked as a successors of A'
 #
 # o   Ad
 # |`:
 # | x A'
 # |'|
 # o | A
 # |/
 # o Z
 #
 # But by transitivity Ad is also a successors of A. To avoid having Ad marked
 # as bumped too, we add the `bumpedfix` flag to the marker. <A', (Ad,)>.
 # This flag mean that the successors express the changes between the public and
 # bumped version and fix the situation, breaking the transitivity of
 # "bumped" here.
 bumpedfix = 1
 usingsha256 = 2
 
 ## Parsing and writing of version "0"
 #
 # The header is followed by the markers. Each marker is made of:
 #
 # - 1 uint8 : number of new changesets "N", can be zero.
 #
 # - 1 uint32: metadata size "M" in bytes.
 #
 # - 1 byte: a bit field. It is reserved for flags used in common
 #   obsolete marker operations, to avoid repeated decoding of metadata
 #   entries.
 #
 # - 20 bytes: obsoleted changeset identifier.
 #
 # - N*20 bytes: new changesets identifiers.
 #
 # - M bytes: metadata as a sequence of nul-terminated strings. Each
 #   string contains a key and a value, separated by a colon ':', without
 #   additional encoding. Keys cannot contain '\0' or ':' and values
 #   cannot contain '\0'.
 _fm0version = 0
 _fm0fixed   = '>BIB20s'
 _fm0node = '20s'
 _fm0fsize = _calcsize(_fm0fixed)
 _fm0fnodesize = _calcsize(_fm0node)
 
 def _fm0readmarkers(data, off):
     # Loop on markers
     l = len(data)
     while off + _fm0fsize <= l:
         # read fixed part
         cur = data[off:off + _fm0fsize]
         off += _fm0fsize
         numsuc, mdsize, flags, pre = _unpack(_fm0fixed, cur)
         # read replacement
         sucs = ()
         if numsuc:
             s = (_fm0fnodesize * numsuc)
             cur = data[off:off + s]
             sucs = _unpack(_fm0node * numsuc, cur)
             off += s
         # read metadata
         # (metadata will be decoded on demand)
         metadata = data[off:off + mdsize]
         if len(metadata) != mdsize:
             raise error.Abort(_('parsing obsolete marker: metadata is too '
                                'short, %d bytes expected, got %d')
                              % (mdsize, len(metadata)))
         off += mdsize
         metadata = _fm0decodemeta(metadata)
         try:
             when, offset = metadata.pop('date', '0 0').split(' ')
             date = float(when), int(offset)
         except ValueError:
             date = (0., 0)
         parents = None
         if 'p2' in metadata:
             parents = (metadata.pop('p1', None), metadata.pop('p2', None))
         elif 'p1' in metadata:
             parents = (metadata.pop('p1', None),)
         elif 'p0' in metadata:
             parents = ()
         if parents is not None:
             try:
                 parents = tuple(node.bin(p) for p in parents)
                 # if parent content is not a nodeid, drop the data
                 for p in parents:
                     if len(p) != 20:
                         parents = None
                         break
             except TypeError:
                 # if content cannot be translated to nodeid drop the data.
                 parents = None
 
         metadata = tuple(sorted(metadata.iteritems()))
 
         yield (pre, sucs, flags, metadata, date, parents)
 
 def _fm0encodeonemarker(marker):
     pre, sucs, flags, metadata, date, parents = marker
     if flags & usingsha256:
         raise error.Abort(_('cannot handle sha256 with old obsstore format'))
     metadata = dict(metadata)
     time, tz = date
     metadata['date'] = '%r %i' % (time, tz)
     if parents is not None:
         if not parents:
             # mark that we explicitly recorded no parents
             metadata['p0'] = ''
         for i, p in enumerate(parents, 1):
             metadata['p%i' % i] = node.hex(p)
     metadata = _fm0encodemeta(metadata)
     numsuc = len(sucs)
     format = _fm0fixed + (_fm0node * numsuc)
     data = [numsuc, len(metadata), flags, pre]
     data.extend(sucs)
     return _pack(format, *data) + metadata
 
 def _fm0encodemeta(meta):
     """Return encoded metadata string to string mapping.
 
     Assume no ':' in key and no '\0' in both key and value."""
     for key, value in meta.iteritems():
         if ':' in key or '\0' in key:
             raise ValueError("':' and '\0' are forbidden in metadata key'")
         if '\0' in value:
             raise ValueError("':' is forbidden in metadata value'")
     return '\0'.join(['%s:%s' % (k, meta[k]) for k in sorted(meta)])
 
 def _fm0decodemeta(data):
     """Return string to string dictionary from encoded version."""
     d = {}
     for l in data.split('\0'):
         if l:
             key, value = l.split(':')
             d[key] = value
     return d
 
 ## Parsing and writing of version "1"
 #
 # The header is followed by the markers. Each marker is made of:
 #
 # - uint32: total size of the marker (including this field)
 #
 # - float64: date in seconds since epoch
 #
 # - int16: timezone offset in minutes
 #
 # - uint16: a bit field. It is reserved for flags used in common
 #   obsolete marker operations, to avoid repeated decoding of metadata
 #   entries.
 #
 # - uint8: number of successors "N", can be zero.
 #
 # - uint8: number of parents "P", can be zero.
 #
 #     0: parents data stored but no parent,
 #     1: one parent stored,
 #     2: two parents stored,
 #     3: no parent data stored
 #
 # - uint8: number of metadata entries M
 #
 # - 20 or 32 bytes: precursor changeset identifier.
 #
 # - N*(20 or 32) bytes: successors changesets identifiers.
 #
 # - P*(20 or 32) bytes: parents of the precursors changesets.
 #
 # - M*(uint8, uint8): size of all metadata entries (key and value)
 #
 # - remaining bytes: the metadata, each (key, value) pair after the other.
 _fm1version = 1
 _fm1fixed = '>IdhHBBB20s'
 _fm1nodesha1 = '20s'
 _fm1nodesha256 = '32s'
 _fm1nodesha1size = _calcsize(_fm1nodesha1)
 _fm1nodesha256size = _calcsize(_fm1nodesha256)
 _fm1fsize = _calcsize(_fm1fixed)
 _fm1parentnone = 3
 _fm1parentshift = 14
 _fm1parentmask = (_fm1parentnone << _fm1parentshift)
 _fm1metapair = 'BB'
 _fm1metapairsize = _calcsize('BB')
 
 def _fm1purereadmarkers(data, off):
     # make some global constants local for performance
     noneflag = _fm1parentnone
     sha2flag = usingsha256
     sha1size = _fm1nodesha1size
     sha2size = _fm1nodesha256size
     sha1fmt = _fm1nodesha1
     sha2fmt = _fm1nodesha256
     metasize = _fm1metapairsize
     metafmt = _fm1metapair
     fsize = _fm1fsize
     unpack = _unpack
 
     # Loop on markers
     stop = len(data) - _fm1fsize
     ufixed = struct.Struct(_fm1fixed).unpack
 
     while off <= stop:
         # read fixed part
         o1 = off + fsize
         t, secs, tz, flags, numsuc, numpar, nummeta, prec = ufixed(data[off:o1])
 
         if flags & sha2flag:
             # FIXME: prec was read as a SHA1, needs to be amended
 
             # read 0 or more successors
             if numsuc == 1:
                 o2 = o1 + sha2size
                 sucs = (data[o1:o2],)
             else:
                 o2 = o1 + sha2size * numsuc
                 sucs = unpack(sha2fmt * numsuc, data[o1:o2])
 
             # read parents
             if numpar == noneflag:
                 o3 = o2
                 parents = None
             elif numpar == 1:
                 o3 = o2 + sha2size
                 parents = (data[o2:o3],)
             else:
                 o3 = o2 + sha2size * numpar
                 parents = unpack(sha2fmt * numpar, data[o2:o3])
         else:
             # read 0 or more successors
             if numsuc == 1:
                 o2 = o1 + sha1size
                 sucs = (data[o1:o2],)
             else:
                 o2 = o1 + sha1size * numsuc
                 sucs = unpack(sha1fmt * numsuc, data[o1:o2])
 
             # read parents
             if numpar == noneflag:
                 o3 = o2
                 parents = None
             elif numpar == 1:
                 o3 = o2 + sha1size
                 parents = (data[o2:o3],)
             else:
                 o3 = o2 + sha1size * numpar
                 parents = unpack(sha1fmt * numpar, data[o2:o3])
 
         # read metadata
         off = o3 + metasize * nummeta
         metapairsize = unpack('>' + (metafmt * nummeta), data[o3:off])
         metadata = []
         for idx in xrange(0, len(metapairsize), 2):
             o1 = off + metapairsize[idx]
             o2 = o1 + metapairsize[idx + 1]
             metadata.append((data[off:o1], data[o1:o2]))
             off = o2
 
         yield (prec, sucs, flags, tuple(metadata), (secs, tz * 60), parents)
 
 def _fm1encodeonemarker(marker):
     pre, sucs, flags, metadata, date, parents = marker
     # determine node size
     _fm1node = _fm1nodesha1
     if flags & usingsha256:
         _fm1node = _fm1nodesha256
     numsuc = len(sucs)
     numextranodes = numsuc
     if parents is None:
         numpar = _fm1parentnone
     else:
         numpar = len(parents)
         numextranodes += numpar
     formatnodes = _fm1node * numextranodes
     formatmeta = _fm1metapair * len(metadata)
     format = _fm1fixed + formatnodes + formatmeta
     # tz is stored in minutes so we divide by 60
     tz = date[1]//60
     data = [None, date[0], tz, flags, numsuc, numpar, len(metadata), pre]
     data.extend(sucs)
     if parents is not None:
         data.extend(parents)
     totalsize = _calcsize(format)
     for key, value in metadata:
         lk = len(key)
         lv = len(value)
         data.append(lk)
         data.append(lv)
         totalsize += lk + lv
     data[0] = totalsize
     data = [_pack(format, *data)]
     for key, value in metadata:
         data.append(key)
         data.append(value)
     return ''.join(data)
 
 def _fm1readmarkers(data, off):
     native = getattr(parsers, 'fm1readmarkers', None)
     if not native:
         return _fm1purereadmarkers(data, off)
     stop = len(data) - _fm1fsize
     return native(data, off, stop)
 
 # mapping to read/write various marker formats
 # <version> -> (decoder, encoder)
 formats = {_fm0version: (_fm0readmarkers, _fm0encodeonemarker),
            _fm1version: (_fm1readmarkers, _fm1encodeonemarker)}
 
 @util.nogc
 def _readmarkers(data):
     """Read and enumerate markers from raw data"""
     off = 0
     diskversion = _unpack('>B', data[off:off + 1])[0]
     off += 1
     if diskversion not in formats:
         raise error.Abort(_('parsing obsolete marker: unknown version %r')
                          % diskversion)
     return diskversion, formats[diskversion][0](data, off)
 
 def encodemarkers(markers, addheader=False, version=_fm0version):
     # Kept separate from flushmarkers(), it will be reused for
     # markers exchange.
     encodeone = formats[version][1]
     if addheader:
         yield _pack('>B', version)
     for marker in markers:
         yield encodeone(marker)
 
 
 class marker(object):
     """Wrap obsolete marker raw data"""
 
     def __init__(self, repo, data):
         # the repo argument will be used to create changectx in later version
         self._repo = repo
         self._data = data
         self._decodedmeta = None
 
     def __hash__(self):
         return hash(self._data)
 
     def __eq__(self, other):
         if type(other) != type(self):
             return False
         return self._data == other._data
 
     def precnode(self):
         """Precursor changeset node identifier"""
         return self._data[0]
 
     def succnodes(self):
         """List of successor changesets node identifiers"""
         return self._data[1]
 
     def parentnodes(self):
         """Parents of the precursors (None if not recorded)"""
         return self._data[5]
 
     def metadata(self):
         """Decoded metadata dictionary"""
         return dict(self._data[3])
 
     def date(self):
         """Creation date as (unixtime, offset)"""
         return self._data[4]
 
     def flags(self):
         """The flags field of the marker"""
         return self._data[2]
 
 @util.nogc
 def _addsuccessors(successors, markers):
     for mark in markers:
         successors.setdefault(mark[0], set()).add(mark)
 
 @util.nogc
 def _addprecursors(precursors, markers):
     for mark in markers:
         for suc in mark[1]:
             precursors.setdefault(suc, set()).add(mark)
 
 @util.nogc
 def _addchildren(children, markers):
     for mark in markers:
         parents = mark[5]
         if parents is not None:
             for p in parents:
                 children.setdefault(p, set()).add(mark)
 
 def _checkinvalidmarkers(markers):
     """search for marker with invalid data and raise error if needed
 
     Exist as a separated function to allow the evolve extension for a more
     subtle handling.
     """
     for mark in markers:
         if node.nullid in mark[1]:
             raise error.Abort(_('bad obsolescence marker detected: '
                                'invalid successors nullid'))
 
 class obsstore(object):
     """Store obsolete markers
 
     Markers can be accessed with two mappings:
     - precursors[x] -> set(markers on precursors edges of x)
     - successors[x] -> set(markers on successors edges of x)
     - children[x]   -> set(markers on precursors edges of children(x)
     """
 
     fields = ('prec', 'succs', 'flag', 'meta', 'date', 'parents')
     # prec:    nodeid, precursor changesets
     # succs:   tuple of nodeid, successor changesets (0-N length)
     # flag:    integer, flag field carrying modifier for the markers (see doc)
     # meta:    binary blob, encoded metadata dictionary
     # date:    (float, int) tuple, date of marker creation
     # parents: (tuple of nodeid) or None, parents of precursors
     #          None is used when no data has been recorded
 
     def __init__(self, svfs, defaultformat=_fm1version, readonly=False):
         # caches for various obsolescence related cache
         self.caches = {}
         self.svfs = svfs
         self._version = defaultformat
         self._readonly = readonly
 
     def __iter__(self):
         return iter(self._all)
 
     def __len__(self):
         return len(self._all)
 
     def __nonzero__(self):
         if not self._cached('_all'):
             try:
                 return self.svfs.stat('obsstore').st_size > 1
             except OSError as inst:
                 if inst.errno != errno.ENOENT:
                     raise
                 # just build an empty _all list if no obsstore exists, which
                 # avoids further stat() syscalls
                 pass
         return bool(self._all)
 
     __bool__ = __nonzero__
 
     @property
     def readonly(self):
         """True if marker creation is disabled
 
         Remove me in the future when obsolete marker is always on."""
         return self._readonly
 
     def create(self, transaction, prec, succs=(), flag=0, parents=None,
                date=None, metadata=None, ui=None):
         """obsolete: add a new obsolete marker
 
         * ensuring it is hashable
         * check mandatory metadata
         * encode metadata
 
         If you are a human writing code creating marker you want to use the
         `createmarkers` function in this module instead.
 
         return True if a new marker have been added, False if the markers
         already existed (no op).
         """
         if metadata is None:
             metadata = {}
         if date is None:
             if 'date' in metadata:
                 # as a courtesy for out-of-tree extensions
                 date = util.parsedate(metadata.pop('date'))
             elif ui is not None:
                 date = ui.configdate('devel', 'default-date')
                 if date is None:
                     date = util.makedate()
             else:
                 date = util.makedate()
         if len(prec) != 20:
             raise ValueError(prec)
         for succ in succs:
             if len(succ) != 20:
                 raise ValueError(succ)
         if prec in succs:
             raise ValueError(_('in-marker cycle with %s') % node.hex(prec))
 
         metadata = tuple(sorted(metadata.iteritems()))
 
         marker = (str(prec), tuple(succs), int(flag), metadata, date, parents)
         return bool(self.add(transaction, [marker]))
 
     def add(self, transaction, markers):
         """Add new markers to the store
 
         Take care of filtering duplicate.
         Return the number of new marker."""
         if self._readonly:
             raise error.Abort(_('creating obsolete markers is not enabled on '
                               'this repo'))
         known = set(self._all)
         new = []
         for m in markers:
             if m not in known:
                 known.add(m)
                 new.append(m)
         if new:
             f = self.svfs('obsstore', 'ab')
             try:
                 offset = f.tell()
                 transaction.add('obsstore', offset)
                 # offset == 0: new file - add the version header
                 for bytes in encodemarkers(new, offset == 0, self._version):
                     f.write(bytes)
             finally:
                 # XXX: f.close() == filecache invalidation == obsstore rebuilt.
                 # call 'filecacheentry.refresh()'  here
                 f.close()
             self._addmarkers(new)
             # new marker *may* have changed several set. invalidate the cache.
             self.caches.clear()
         # records the number of new markers for the transaction hooks
         previous = int(transaction.hookargs.get('new_obsmarkers', '0'))
         transaction.hookargs['new_obsmarkers'] = str(previous + len(new))
         return len(new)
 
     def mergemarkers(self, transaction, data):
         """merge a binary stream of markers inside the obsstore
 
         Returns the number of new markers added."""
         version, markers = _readmarkers(data)
         return self.add(transaction, markers)
 
     @propertycache
     def _all(self):
         data = self.svfs.tryread('obsstore')
         if not data:
             return []
         self._version, markers = _readmarkers(data)
         markers = list(markers)
         _checkinvalidmarkers(markers)
         return markers
 
     @propertycache
     def successors(self):
         successors = {}
         _addsuccessors(successors, self._all)
         return successors
 
     @propertycache
     def precursors(self):
         precursors = {}
         _addprecursors(precursors, self._all)
         return precursors
 
     @propertycache
     def children(self):
         children = {}
         _addchildren(children, self._all)
         return children
 
     def _cached(self, attr):
         return attr in self.__dict__
 
     def _addmarkers(self, markers):
         markers = list(markers) # to allow repeated iteration
         self._all.extend(markers)
         if self._cached('successors'):
             _addsuccessors(self.successors, markers)
         if self._cached('precursors'):
             _addprecursors(self.precursors, markers)
         if self._cached('children'):
             _addchildren(self.children, markers)
         _checkinvalidmarkers(markers)
 
     def relevantmarkers(self, nodes):
         """return a set of all obsolescence markers relevant to a set of nodes.
 
         "relevant" to a set of nodes mean:
 
         - marker that use this changeset as successor
         - prune marker of direct children on this changeset
         - recursive application of the two rules on precursors of these markers
 
         It is a set so you cannot rely on order."""
 
         pendingnodes = set(nodes)
         seenmarkers = set()
         seennodes = set(pendingnodes)
         precursorsmarkers = self.precursors
+        succsmarkers = self.successors
         children = self.children
         while pendingnodes:
             direct = set()
             for current in pendingnodes:
                 direct.update(precursorsmarkers.get(current, ()))
                 pruned = [m for m in children.get(current, ()) if not m[1]]
                 direct.update(pruned)
+                pruned = [m for m in succsmarkers.get(current, ()) if not m[1]]
+                direct.update(pruned)
             direct -= seenmarkers
             pendingnodes = set([m[0] for m in direct])
             seenmarkers |= direct
             pendingnodes -= seennodes
             seennodes |= pendingnodes
         return seenmarkers
 
 def commonversion(versions):
     """Return the newest version listed in both versions and our local formats.
 
     Returns None if no common version exists.
     """
     versions.sort(reverse=True)
     # search for highest version known on both side
     for v in versions:
         if v in formats:
             return v
     return None
 
 # arbitrary picked to fit into 8K limit from HTTP server
 # you have to take in account:
 # - the version header
 # - the base85 encoding
 _maxpayload = 5300
 
 def _pushkeyescape(markers):
     """encode markers into a dict suitable for pushkey exchange
 
     - binary data is base85 encoded
     - split in chunks smaller than 5300 bytes"""
     keys = {}
     parts = []
     currentlen = _maxpayload * 2  # ensure we create a new part
     for marker in markers:
         nextdata = _fm0encodeonemarker(marker)
         if (len(nextdata) + currentlen > _maxpayload):
             currentpart = []
             currentlen = 0
             parts.append(currentpart)
         currentpart.append(nextdata)
         currentlen += len(nextdata)
     for idx, part in enumerate(reversed(parts)):
         data = ''.join([_pack('>B', _fm0version)] + part)
         keys['dump%i' % idx] = util.b85encode(data)
     return keys
 
 def listmarkers(repo):
     """List markers over pushkey"""
     if not repo.obsstore:
         return {}
     return _pushkeyescape(sorted(repo.obsstore))
 
 def pushmarker(repo, key, old, new):
     """Push markers over pushkey"""
     if not key.startswith('dump'):
         repo.ui.warn(_('unknown key: %r') % key)
         return 0
     if old:
         repo.ui.warn(_('unexpected old value for %r') % key)
         return 0
     data = util.b85decode(new)
     lock = repo.lock()
     try:
         tr = repo.transaction('pushkey: obsolete markers')
         try:
             repo.obsstore.mergemarkers(tr, data)
             repo.invalidatevolatilesets()
             tr.close()
             return 1
         finally:
             tr.release()
     finally:
         lock.release()
 
 def getmarkers(repo, nodes=None):
     """returns markers known in a repository
 
     If <nodes> is specified, only markers "relevant" to those nodes are are
     returned"""
     if nodes is None:
         rawmarkers = repo.obsstore
     else:
         rawmarkers = repo.obsstore.relevantmarkers(nodes)
 
     for markerdata in rawmarkers:
         yield marker(repo, markerdata)
 
 def relevantmarkers(repo, node):
     """all obsolete markers relevant to some revision"""
     for markerdata in repo.obsstore.relevantmarkers(node):
         yield marker(repo, markerdata)
 
 
 def precursormarkers(ctx):
     """obsolete marker marking this changeset as a successors"""
     for data in ctx.repo().obsstore.precursors.get(ctx.node(), ()):
         yield marker(ctx.repo(), data)
 
 def successormarkers(ctx):
     """obsolete marker making this changeset obsolete"""
     for data in ctx.repo().obsstore.successors.get(ctx.node(), ()):
         yield marker(ctx.repo(), data)
 
 def allsuccessors(obsstore, nodes, ignoreflags=0):
     """Yield node for every successor of <nodes>.
 
     Some successors may be unknown locally.
 
     This is a linear yield unsuited to detecting split changesets. It includes
     initial nodes too."""
     remaining = set(nodes)
     seen = set(remaining)
     while remaining:
         current = remaining.pop()
         yield current
         for mark in obsstore.successors.get(current, ()):
             # ignore marker flagged with specified flag
             if mark[2] & ignoreflags:
                 continue
             for suc in mark[1]:
                 if suc not in seen:
                     seen.add(suc)
                     remaining.add(suc)
 
 def allprecursors(obsstore, nodes, ignoreflags=0):
     """Yield node for every precursors of <nodes>.
 
     Some precursors may be unknown locally.
 
     This is a linear yield unsuited to detecting folded changesets. It includes
     initial nodes too."""
 
     remaining = set(nodes)
     seen = set(remaining)
     while remaining:
         current = remaining.pop()
         yield current
         for mark in obsstore.precursors.get(current, ()):
             # ignore marker flagged with specified flag
             if mark[2] & ignoreflags:
                 continue
             suc = mark[0]
             if suc not in seen:
                 seen.add(suc)
                 remaining.add(suc)
 
 def foreground(repo, nodes):
     """return all nodes in the "foreground" of other node
 
     The foreground of a revision is anything reachable using parent -> children
     or precursor -> successor relation. It is very similar to "descendant" but
     augmented with obsolescence information.
 
     Beware that possible obsolescence cycle may result if complex situation.
     """
     repo = repo.unfiltered()
     foreground = set(repo.set('%ln::', nodes))
     if repo.obsstore:
         # We only need this complicated logic if there is obsolescence
         # XXX will probably deserve an optimised revset.
         nm = repo.changelog.nodemap
         plen = -1
         # compute the whole set of successors or descendants
         while len(foreground) != plen:
             plen = len(foreground)
             succs = set(c.node() for c in foreground)
             mutable = [c.node() for c in foreground if c.mutable()]
             succs.update(allsuccessors(repo.obsstore, mutable))
             known = (n for n in succs if n in nm)
             foreground = set(repo.set('%ln::', known))
     return set(c.node() for c in foreground)
 
 
 def successorssets(repo, initialnode, cache=None):
     """Return set of all latest successors of initial nodes
 
     The successors set of a changeset A are the group of revisions that succeed
     A. It succeeds A as a consistent whole, each revision being only a partial
     replacement. The successors set contains non-obsolete changesets only.
 
     This function returns the full list of successor sets which is why it
     returns a list of tuples and not just a single tuple. Each tuple is a valid
     successors set. Note that (A,) may be a valid successors set for changeset A
     (see below).
 
     In most cases, a changeset A will have a single element (e.g. the changeset
     A is replaced by A') in its successors set. Though, it is also common for a
     changeset A to have no elements in its successor set (e.g. the changeset
     has been pruned). Therefore, the returned list of successors sets will be
     [(A',)] or [], respectively.
 
     When a changeset A is split into A' and B', however, it will result in a
     successors set containing more than a single element, i.e. [(A',B')].
     Divergent changesets will result in multiple successors sets, i.e. [(A',),
     (A'')].
 
     If a changeset A is not obsolete, then it will conceptually have no
     successors set. To distinguish this from a pruned changeset, the successor
     set will contain itself only, i.e. [(A,)].
 
     Finally, successors unknown locally are considered to be pruned (obsoleted
     without any successors).
 
     The optional `cache` parameter is a dictionary that may contain precomputed
     successors sets. It is meant to reuse the computation of a previous call to
     `successorssets` when multiple calls are made at the same time. The cache
     dictionary is updated in place. The caller is responsible for its life
     span. Code that makes multiple calls to `successorssets` *must* use this
     cache mechanism or suffer terrible performance.
     """
 
     succmarkers = repo.obsstore.successors
 
     # Stack of nodes we search successors sets for
     toproceed = [initialnode]
     # set version of above list for fast loop detection
     # element added to "toproceed" must be added here
     stackedset = set(toproceed)
     if cache is None:
         cache = {}
 
     # This while loop is the flattened version of a recursive search for
     # successors sets
     #
     # def successorssets(x):
     #    successors = directsuccessors(x)
     #    ss = [[]]
     #    for succ in directsuccessors(x):
     #        # product as in itertools cartesian product
     #        ss = product(ss, successorssets(succ))
     #    return ss
     #
     # But we can not use plain recursive calls here:
     # - that would blow the python call stack
     # - obsolescence markers may have cycles, we need to handle them.
     #
     # The `toproceed` list act as our call stack. Every node we search
     # successors set for are stacked there.
     #
     # The `stackedset` is set version of this stack used to check if a node is
     # already stacked. This check is used to detect cycles and prevent infinite
     # loop.
     #
     # successors set of all nodes are stored in the `cache` dictionary.
     #
     # After this while loop ends we use the cache to return the successors sets
     # for the node requested by the caller.
     while toproceed:
         # Every iteration tries to compute the successors sets of the topmost
         # node of the stack: CURRENT.
         #
         # There are four possible outcomes:
         #
         # 1) We already know the successors sets of CURRENT:
         #    -> mission accomplished, pop it from the stack.
         # 2) Node is not obsolete:
         #    -> the node is its own successors sets. Add it to the cache.
         # 3) We do not know successors set of direct successors of CURRENT:
         #    -> We add those successors to the stack.
         # 4) We know successors sets of all direct successors of CURRENT:
         #    -> We can compute CURRENT successors set and add it to the
         #       cache.
         #
         current = toproceed[-1]
         if current in cache:
             # case (1): We already know the successors sets
             stackedset.remove(toproceed.pop())
         elif current not in succmarkers:
             # case (2): The node is not obsolete.
             if current in repo:
                 # We have a valid last successors.
                 cache[current] = [(current,)]
             else:
                 # Final obsolete version is unknown locally.
                 # Do not count that as a valid successors
                 cache[current] = []
         else:
             # cases (3) and (4)
             #
             # We proceed in two phases. Phase 1 aims to distinguish case (3)
             # from case (4):
             #
             #     For each direct successors of CURRENT, we check whether its
             #     successors sets are known. If they are not, we stack the
             #     unknown node and proceed to the next iteration of the while
             #     loop. (case 3)
             #
             #     During this step, we may detect obsolescence cycles: a node
             #     with unknown successors sets but already in the call stack.
             #     In such a situation, we arbitrary set the successors sets of
             #     the node to nothing (node pruned) to break the cycle.
             #
             #     If no break was encountered we proceed to phase 2.
             #
             # Phase 2 computes successors sets of CURRENT (case 4); see details
             # in phase 2 itself.
             #
             # Note the two levels of iteration in each phase.
             # - The first one handles obsolescence markers using CURRENT as
             #   precursor (successors markers of CURRENT).
             #
             #   Having multiple entry here means divergence.
             #
             # - The second one handles successors defined in each marker.
             #
             #   Having none means pruned node, multiple successors means split,
             #   single successors are standard replacement.
             #
             for mark in sorted(succmarkers[current]):
                 for suc in mark[1]:
                     if suc not in cache:
                         if suc in stackedset:
                             # cycle breaking
                             cache[suc] = []
                         else:
                             # case (3) If we have not computed successors sets
                             # of one of those successors we add it to the
                             # `toproceed` stack and stop all work for this
                             # iteration.
                             toproceed.append(suc)
                             stackedset.add(suc)
                             break
                 else:
                     continue
                 break
             else:
                 # case (4): we know all successors sets of all direct
                 # successors
                 #
                 # Successors set contributed by each marker depends on the
                 # successors sets of all its "successors" node.
                 #
                 # Each different marker is a divergence in the obsolescence
                 # history. It contributes successors sets distinct from other
                 # markers.
                 #
                 # Within a marker, a successor may have divergent successors
                 # sets. In such a case, the marker will contribute multiple
                 # divergent successors sets. If multiple successors have
                 # divergent successors sets, a Cartesian product is used.
                 #
                 # At the end we post-process successors sets to remove
                 # duplicated entry and successors set that are strict subset of
                 # another one.
                 succssets = []
                 for mark in sorted(succmarkers[current]):
                     # successors sets contributed by this marker
                     markss = [[]]
                     for suc in mark[1]:
                         # cardinal product with previous successors
                         productresult = []
                         for prefix in markss:
                             for suffix in cache[suc]:
                                 newss = list(prefix)
                                 for part in suffix:
                                     # do not duplicated entry in successors set
                                     # first entry wins.
                                     if part not in newss:
                                         newss.append(part)
                                 productresult.append(newss)
                         markss = productresult
                     succssets.extend(markss)
                 # remove duplicated and subset
                 seen = []
                 final = []
                 candidate = sorted(((set(s), s) for s in succssets if s),
                                    key=lambda x: len(x[1]), reverse=True)
                 for setversion, listversion in candidate:
                     for seenset in seen:
                         if setversion.issubset(seenset):
                             break
                     else:
                         final.append(listversion)
                         seen.append(setversion)
                 final.reverse() # put small successors set first
                 cache[current] = final
     return cache[initialnode]
 
 # mapping of 'set-name' -> <function to compute this set>
 cachefuncs = {}
 def cachefor(name):
     """Decorator to register a function as computing the cache for a set"""
     def decorator(func):
         assert name not in cachefuncs
         cachefuncs[name] = func
         return func
     return decorator
 
 def getrevs(repo, name):
     """Return the set of revision that belong to the <name> set
 
     Such access may compute the set and cache it for future use"""
     repo = repo.unfiltered()
     if not repo.obsstore:
         return frozenset()
     if name not in repo.obsstore.caches:
         repo.obsstore.caches[name] = cachefuncs[name](repo)
     return repo.obsstore.caches[name]
 
 # To be simple we need to invalidate obsolescence cache when:
 #
 # - new changeset is added:
 # - public phase is changed
 # - obsolescence marker are added
 # - strip is used a repo
 def clearobscaches(repo):
     """Remove all obsolescence related cache from a repo
 
     This remove all cache in obsstore is the obsstore already exist on the
     repo.
 
     (We could be smarter here given the exact event that trigger the cache
     clearing)"""
     # only clear cache is there is obsstore data in this repo
     if 'obsstore' in repo._filecache:
         repo.obsstore.caches.clear()
 
 @cachefor('obsolete')
 def _computeobsoleteset(repo):
     """the set of obsolete revisions"""
     obs = set()
     getnode = repo.changelog.node
     notpublic = repo._phasecache.getrevset(repo, (phases.draft, phases.secret))
     for r in notpublic:
         if getnode(r) in repo.obsstore.successors:
             obs.add(r)
     return obs
 
 @cachefor('unstable')
 def _computeunstableset(repo):
     """the set of non obsolete revisions with obsolete parents"""
     revs = [(ctx.rev(), ctx) for ctx in
             repo.set('(not public()) and (not obsolete())')]
     revs.sort(key=lambda x:x[0])
     unstable = set()
     for rev, ctx in revs:
         # A rev is unstable if one of its parent is obsolete or unstable
         # this works since we traverse following growing rev order
         if any((x.obsolete() or (x.rev() in unstable))
                 for x in ctx.parents()):
             unstable.add(rev)
     return unstable
 
 @cachefor('suspended')
 def _computesuspendedset(repo):
     """the set of obsolete parents with non obsolete descendants"""
     suspended = repo.changelog.ancestors(getrevs(repo, 'unstable'))
     return set(r for r in getrevs(repo, 'obsolete') if r in suspended)
 
 @cachefor('extinct')
 def _computeextinctset(repo):
     """the set of obsolete parents without non obsolete descendants"""
     return getrevs(repo, 'obsolete') - getrevs(repo, 'suspended')
 
 
 @cachefor('bumped')
 def _computebumpedset(repo):
     """the set of revs trying to obsolete public revisions"""
     bumped = set()
     # util function (avoid attribute lookup in the loop)
     phase = repo._phasecache.phase # would be faster to grab the full list
     public = phases.public
     cl = repo.changelog
     torev = cl.nodemap.get
     for ctx in repo.set('(not public()) and (not obsolete())'):
         rev = ctx.rev()
         # We only evaluate mutable, non-obsolete revision
         node = ctx.node()
         # (future) A cache of precursors may worth if split is very common
         for pnode in allprecursors(repo.obsstore, [node],
                                    ignoreflags=bumpedfix):
             prev = torev(pnode) # unfiltered! but so is phasecache
             if (prev is not None) and (phase(repo, prev) <= public):
                 # we have a public precursor
                 bumped.add(rev)
                 break # Next draft!
     return bumped
 
 @cachefor('divergent')
 def _computedivergentset(repo):
     """the set of rev that compete to be the final successors of some revision.
     """
     divergent = set()
     obsstore = repo.obsstore
     newermap = {}
     for ctx in repo.set('(not public()) - obsolete()'):
         mark = obsstore.precursors.get(ctx.node(), ())
         toprocess = set(mark)
         seen = set()
         while toprocess:
             prec = toprocess.pop()[0]
             if prec in seen:
                 continue # emergency cycle hanging prevention
             seen.add(prec)
             if prec not in newermap:
                 successorssets(repo, prec, newermap)
             newer = [n for n in newermap[prec] if n]
             if len(newer) > 1:
                 divergent.add(ctx.rev())
                 break
             toprocess.update(obsstore.precursors.get(prec, ()))
     return divergent
 
 
 def createmarkers(repo, relations, flag=0, date=None, metadata=None,
                   operation=None):
     """Add obsolete markers between changesets in a repo
 
     <relations> must be an iterable of (<old>, (<new>, ...)[,{metadata}])
     tuple. `old` and `news` are changectx. metadata is an optional dictionary
     containing metadata for this marker only. It is merged with the global
     metadata specified through the `metadata` argument of this function,
 
     Trying to obsolete a public changeset will raise an exception.
 
     Current user and date are used except if specified otherwise in the
     metadata attribute.
 
     This function operates within a transaction of its own, but does
     not take any lock on the repo.
     """
     # prepare metadata
     if metadata is None:
         metadata = {}
     if 'user' not in metadata:
         metadata['user'] = repo.ui.username()
     useoperation = repo.ui.configbool('experimental',
                                       'evolution.track-operation',
                                       False)
     if useoperation and operation:
         metadata['operation'] = operation
     tr = repo.transaction('add-obsolescence-marker')
     try:
         markerargs = []
         for rel in relations:
             prec = rel[0]
             sucs = rel[1]
             localmetadata = metadata.copy()
             if 2 < len(rel):
                 localmetadata.update(rel[2])
 
             if not prec.mutable():
                 raise error.Abort(_("cannot obsolete public changeset: %s")
                                  % prec,
                                  hint="see 'hg help phases' for details")
             nprec = prec.node()
             nsucs = tuple(s.node() for s in sucs)
             npare = None
             if not nsucs:
                 npare = tuple(p.node() for p in prec.parents())
             if nprec in nsucs:
                 raise error.Abort(_("changeset %s cannot obsolete itself")
                                   % prec)
 
             # Creating the marker causes the hidden cache to become invalid,
             # which causes recomputation when we ask for prec.parents() above.
             # Resulting in n^2 behavior.  So let's prepare all of the args
             # first, then create the markers.
             markerargs.append((nprec, nsucs, npare, localmetadata))
 
         for args in markerargs:
             nprec, nsucs, npare, localmetadata = args
             repo.obsstore.create(tr, nprec, nsucs, flag, parents=npare,
                                  date=date, metadata=localmetadata,
                                  ui=repo.ui)
             repo.filteredrevcache.clear()
         tr.close()
     finally:
         tr.release()

tests/test-obsolete-bundle-strip.t

@@ -1,102 +1,198 b''
 ==================================================
 Test obsmarkers interaction with bundle and strip
 ==================================================
 
 In practice, this file does not yet contains any tests for bundle and strip.
 But their will be some soon (tm).
 
 For now this test check the logic computing markers relevant to a set of
 revision. That logic will be use by "hg bundle" to select the markers to
 include, and strip to find the markers to backup.
 
 Setup a repository with various case
 ====================================
 
 Config setup
 ------------
 
   $ cat >> $HGRCPATH <<EOF
   > [ui]
   > # simpler log output
   > logtemplate = "{node|short}: {desc}\n"
   > 
   > [experimental]
   > # enable evolution
   > evolution = all
   > 
   > # include obsmarkers in bundle
   > evolution.bundle-obsmarker = yes
   > 
   > [extensions]
   > # needed for some tests
   > strip =
   > [defaults]
   > # we'll query many hidden changeset
   > debugobsolete = --hidden
   > EOF
 
   $ mkcommit() {
   >    echo "$1" > "$1"
   >    hg add "$1"
   >    hg ci -m "$1"
   > }
 
   $ getid() {
   >    hg log --hidden --template '{node}\n' --rev "$1"
   > }
 
   $ mktestrepo () {
   >     [ -n "$1" ] || exit 1
   >     cd $TESTTMP
   >     hg init $1
   >     cd $1
   >     mkcommit ROOT
   > }
 
 root setup
 -------------
 
 simple chain
 ============
 
 .    A0
 .   ⇠ø⇠◔ A1
 .    |/
 .    ●
 
 setup
 -----
 
   $ mktestrepo simple-chain
   $ mkcommit 'C-A0'
   $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
   0 files updated, 0 files merged, 1 files removed, 0 files unresolved
   $ mkcommit 'C-A1'
   created new head
   $ hg debugobsolete a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 `getid 'desc("C-A0")'`
   $ hg debugobsolete `getid 'desc("C-A0")'` a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1
   $ hg debugobsolete a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1 `getid 'desc("C-A1")'`
 
   $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
   0 files updated, 0 files merged, 1 files removed, 0 files unresolved
   $ hg log --hidden -G
   o  cf2c22470d67: C-A1
   |
   | x  84fcb0dfe17b: C-A0
   |/
   @  ea207398892e: ROOT
   
   $ hg debugobsolete
   a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
   84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
   a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1 cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
 
 Actual testing
 --------------
 
   $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A0")'
   a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
   $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A1")'
   84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
   a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
   a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1a1 cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+
+chain with prune children
+=========================
+
+.  ⇠⊗ B0
+.   |
+.  ⇠ø⇠◔ A1
+.     |
+.     ●
+
+setup
+-----
+
+  $ mktestrepo prune
+  $ mkcommit 'C-A0'
+  $ mkcommit 'C-B0'
+  $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
+  0 files updated, 0 files merged, 2 files removed, 0 files unresolved
+  $ mkcommit 'C-A1'
+  created new head
+  $ hg debugobsolete a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 `getid 'desc("C-A0")'`
+  $ hg debugobsolete `getid 'desc("C-A0")'` `getid 'desc("C-A1")'`
+  $ hg debugobsolete --record-parents `getid 'desc("C-B0")'`
+  $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
+  0 files updated, 0 files merged, 1 files removed, 0 files unresolved
+  $ hg log --hidden -G
+  o  cf2c22470d67: C-A1
+  |
+  | x  29f93b1df87b: C-B0
+  | |
+  | x  84fcb0dfe17b: C-A0
+  |/
+  @  ea207398892e: ROOT
+  
+  $ hg debugobsolete
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  29f93b1df87baee1824e014080d8adf145f81783 0 {84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+
+Actual testing
+--------------
+
+  $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A0")'
+  29f93b1df87baee1824e014080d8adf145f81783 0 {84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-B0")'
+  29f93b1df87baee1824e014080d8adf145f81783 0 {84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A1")'
+  29f93b1df87baee1824e014080d8adf145f81783 0 {84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+
+chain with precursors also pruned
+=================================
+
+.   A0 (also pruned)
+.  ⇠ø⇠◔ A1
+.     |
+.     ●
+
+setup
+-----
+
+  $ mktestrepo prune-inline
+  $ mkcommit 'C-A0'
+  $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
+  0 files updated, 0 files merged, 1 files removed, 0 files unresolved
+  $ mkcommit 'C-A1'
+  created new head
+  $ hg debugobsolete a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 `getid 'desc("C-A0")'`
+  $ hg debugobsolete --record-parents `getid 'desc("C-A0")'`
+  $ hg debugobsolete `getid 'desc("C-A0")'` `getid 'desc("C-A1")'`
+  $ hg up 'desc("ROOT")'
+  0 files updated, 0 files merged, 1 files removed, 0 files unresolved
+  $ hg log --hidden -G
+  o  cf2c22470d67: C-A1
+  |
+  | x  84fcb0dfe17b: C-A0
+  |/
+  @  ea207398892e: ROOT
+  
+  $ hg debugobsolete
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 {ea207398892eb49e06441f10dda2a731f0450f20} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+
+Actual testing
+--------------
+
+  $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A0")'
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 {ea207398892eb49e06441f10dda2a731f0450f20} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  $ hg debugobsolete --rev 'desc("C-A1")'
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 {ea207398892eb49e06441f10dda2a731f0450f20} (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a cf2c22470d67233004e934a31184ac2b35389914 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}
+  a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0a0 84fcb0dfe17b256ebae52e05572993b9194c018a 0 (Thu Jan 01 00:00:00 1970 +0000) {'user': 'test'}