verify: update comment to say that lfs doesn't need fulltext to check renames

The reason is that `filelog.renamed()` indirectly calls `filelog.revision()`,
which is what accesses the full text.  However, LFS wraps `filelog.renamed()`
and completely handles the case where an LFS blob is in play by using rawdata.

I've got a test to demonstrate that this is the case, and prevent regressions.
But the `skipread` flag is set on all lfs revisions when using `--no-lfs`,
regardless of whether or not the blobs are local.  Just above this, that flag is
consulted, causing the rename checks to be skipped.  That will need to be
loosened up first.

Differential Revision: https://phab.mercurial-scm.org/D7709

mercurial/verify.py

@@ -1,625 +1,626
 # verify.py - repository integrity checking for Mercurial
 #
 # Copyright 2006, 2007 Matt Mackall <[e-mail]>
 #
 # This software may be used and distributed according to the terms of the
 # GNU General Public License version 2 or any later version.
 
 from __future__ import absolute_import
 
 import os
 
 from .i18n import _
 from .node import (
     nullid,
     short,
 )
 
 from . import (
     error,
     pycompat,
     revlog,
     util,
 )
 
 VERIFY_DEFAULT = 0
 VERIFY_FULL = 1
 
 
 def verify(repo, level=None):
     with repo.lock():
         v = verifier(repo, level)
         return v.verify()
 
 
 def _normpath(f):
     # under hg < 2.4, convert didn't sanitize paths properly, so a
     # converted repo may contain repeated slashes
     while b'//' in f:
         f = f.replace(b'//', b'/')
     return f
 
 
 class verifier(object):
     def __init__(self, repo, level=None):
         self.repo = repo.unfiltered()
         self.ui = repo.ui
         self.match = repo.narrowmatch()
         if level is None:
             level = VERIFY_DEFAULT
         self._level = level
         self.badrevs = set()
         self.errors = 0
         self.warnings = 0
         self.havecl = len(repo.changelog) > 0
         self.havemf = len(repo.manifestlog.getstorage(b'')) > 0
         self.revlogv1 = repo.changelog.version != revlog.REVLOGV0
         self.lrugetctx = util.lrucachefunc(repo.__getitem__)
         self.refersmf = False
         self.fncachewarned = False
         # developer config: verify.skipflags
         self.skipflags = repo.ui.configint(b'verify', b'skipflags')
         self.warnorphanstorefiles = True
 
     def _warn(self, msg):
         """record a "warning" level issue"""
         self.ui.warn(msg + b"\n")
         self.warnings += 1
 
     def _err(self, linkrev, msg, filename=None):
         """record a "error" level issue"""
         if linkrev is not None:
             self.badrevs.add(linkrev)
             linkrev = b"%d" % linkrev
         else:
             linkrev = b'?'
         msg = b"%s: %s" % (linkrev, msg)
         if filename:
             msg = b"%s@%s" % (filename, msg)
         self.ui.warn(b" " + msg + b"\n")
         self.errors += 1
 
     def _exc(self, linkrev, msg, inst, filename=None):
         """record exception raised during the verify process"""
         fmsg = pycompat.bytestr(inst)
         if not fmsg:
             fmsg = pycompat.byterepr(inst)
         self._err(linkrev, b"%s: %s" % (msg, fmsg), filename)
 
     def _checkrevlog(self, obj, name, linkrev):
         """verify high level property of a revlog
 
         - revlog is present,
         - revlog is non-empty,
         - sizes (index and data) are correct,
         - revlog's format version is correct.
         """
         if not len(obj) and (self.havecl or self.havemf):
             self._err(linkrev, _(b"empty or missing %s") % name)
             return
 
         d = obj.checksize()
         if d[0]:
             self._err(None, _(b"data length off by %d bytes") % d[0], name)
         if d[1]:
             self._err(None, _(b"index contains %d extra bytes") % d[1], name)
 
         if obj.version != revlog.REVLOGV0:
             if not self.revlogv1:
                 self._warn(_(b"warning: `%s' uses revlog format 1") % name)
         elif self.revlogv1:
             self._warn(_(b"warning: `%s' uses revlog format 0") % name)
 
     def _checkentry(self, obj, i, node, seen, linkrevs, f):
         """verify a single revlog entry
 
         arguments are:
         - obj:      the source revlog
         - i:        the revision number
         - node:        the revision node id
         - seen:     nodes previously seen for this revlog
         - linkrevs: [changelog-revisions] introducing "node"
         - f:        string label ("changelog", "manifest", or filename)
 
         Performs the following checks:
         - linkrev points to an existing changelog revision,
         - linkrev points to a changelog revision that introduces this revision,
         - linkrev points to the lowest of these changesets,
         - both parents exist in the revlog,
         - the revision is not duplicated.
 
         Return the linkrev of the revision (or None for changelog's revisions).
         """
         lr = obj.linkrev(obj.rev(node))
         if lr < 0 or (self.havecl and lr not in linkrevs):
             if lr < 0 or lr >= len(self.repo.changelog):
                 msg = _(b"rev %d points to nonexistent changeset %d")
             else:
                 msg = _(b"rev %d points to unexpected changeset %d")
             self._err(None, msg % (i, lr), f)
             if linkrevs:
                 if f and len(linkrevs) > 1:
                     try:
                         # attempt to filter down to real linkrevs
                         linkrevs = [
                             l
                             for l in linkrevs
                             if self.lrugetctx(l)[f].filenode() == node
                         ]
                     except Exception:
                         pass
                 self._warn(
                     _(b" (expected %s)")
                     % b" ".join(map(pycompat.bytestr, linkrevs))
                 )
             lr = None  # can't be trusted
 
         try:
             p1, p2 = obj.parents(node)
             if p1 not in seen and p1 != nullid:
                 self._err(
                     lr,
                     _(b"unknown parent 1 %s of %s") % (short(p1), short(node)),
                     f,
                 )
             if p2 not in seen and p2 != nullid:
                 self._err(
                     lr,
                     _(b"unknown parent 2 %s of %s") % (short(p2), short(node)),
                     f,
                 )
         except Exception as inst:
             self._exc(lr, _(b"checking parents of %s") % short(node), inst, f)
 
         if node in seen:
             self._err(lr, _(b"duplicate revision %d (%d)") % (i, seen[node]), f)
         seen[node] = i
         return lr
 
     def verify(self):
         """verify the content of the Mercurial repository
 
         This method run all verifications, displaying issues as they are found.
 
         return 1 if any error have been encountered, 0 otherwise."""
         # initial validation and generic report
         repo = self.repo
         ui = repo.ui
         if not repo.url().startswith(b'file:'):
             raise error.Abort(_(b"cannot verify bundle or remote repos"))
 
         if os.path.exists(repo.sjoin(b"journal")):
             ui.warn(_(b"abandoned transaction found - run hg recover\n"))
 
         if ui.verbose or not self.revlogv1:
             ui.status(
                 _(b"repository uses revlog format %d\n")
                 % (self.revlogv1 and 1 or 0)
             )
 
         # data verification
         mflinkrevs, filelinkrevs = self._verifychangelog()
         filenodes = self._verifymanifest(mflinkrevs)
         del mflinkrevs
         self._crosscheckfiles(filelinkrevs, filenodes)
         totalfiles, filerevisions = self._verifyfiles(filenodes, filelinkrevs)
 
         # final report
         ui.status(
             _(b"checked %d changesets with %d changes to %d files\n")
             % (len(repo.changelog), filerevisions, totalfiles)
         )
         if self.warnings:
             ui.warn(_(b"%d warnings encountered!\n") % self.warnings)
         if self.fncachewarned:
             ui.warn(
                 _(
                     b'hint: run "hg debugrebuildfncache" to recover from '
                     b'corrupt fncache\n'
                 )
             )
         if self.errors:
             ui.warn(_(b"%d integrity errors encountered!\n") % self.errors)
             if self.badrevs:
                 ui.warn(
                     _(b"(first damaged changeset appears to be %d)\n")
                     % min(self.badrevs)
                 )
             return 1
         return 0
 
     def _verifychangelog(self):
         """verify the changelog of a repository
 
         The following checks are performed:
         - all of `_checkrevlog` checks,
         - all of `_checkentry` checks (for each revisions),
         - each revision can be read.
 
         The function returns some of the data observed in the changesets as a
         (mflinkrevs, filelinkrevs) tuples:
         - mflinkrevs:   is a { manifest-node -> [changelog-rev] } mapping
         - filelinkrevs: is a { file-path -> [changelog-rev] } mapping
 
         If a matcher was specified, filelinkrevs will only contains matched
         files.
         """
         ui = self.ui
         repo = self.repo
         match = self.match
         cl = repo.changelog
 
         ui.status(_(b"checking changesets\n"))
         mflinkrevs = {}
         filelinkrevs = {}
         seen = {}
         self._checkrevlog(cl, b"changelog", 0)
         progress = ui.makeprogress(
             _(b'checking'), unit=_(b'changesets'), total=len(repo)
         )
         for i in repo:
             progress.update(i)
             n = cl.node(i)
             self._checkentry(cl, i, n, seen, [i], b"changelog")
 
             try:
                 changes = cl.read(n)
                 if changes[0] != nullid:
                     mflinkrevs.setdefault(changes[0], []).append(i)
                     self.refersmf = True
                 for f in changes[3]:
                     if match(f):
                         filelinkrevs.setdefault(_normpath(f), []).append(i)
             except Exception as inst:
                 self.refersmf = True
                 self._exc(i, _(b"unpacking changeset %s") % short(n), inst)
         progress.complete()
         return mflinkrevs, filelinkrevs
 
     def _verifymanifest(
         self, mflinkrevs, dir=b"", storefiles=None, subdirprogress=None
     ):
         """verify the manifestlog content
 
         Inputs:
         - mflinkrevs:     a {manifest-node -> [changelog-revisions]} mapping
         - dir:            a subdirectory to check (for tree manifest repo)
         - storefiles:     set of currently "orphan" files.
         - subdirprogress: a progress object
 
         This function checks:
         * all of `_checkrevlog` checks (for all manifest related revlogs)
         * all of `_checkentry` checks (for all manifest related revisions)
         * nodes for subdirectory exists in the sub-directory manifest
         * each manifest entries have a file path
         * each manifest node refered in mflinkrevs exist in the manifest log
 
         If tree manifest is in use and a matchers is specified, only the
         sub-directories matching it will be verified.
 
         return a two level mapping:
             {"path" -> { filenode -> changelog-revision}}
 
         This mapping primarily contains entries for every files in the
         repository. In addition, when tree-manifest is used, it also contains
         sub-directory entries.
 
         If a matcher is provided, only matching paths will be included.
         """
         repo = self.repo
         ui = self.ui
         match = self.match
         mfl = self.repo.manifestlog
         mf = mfl.getstorage(dir)
 
         if not dir:
             self.ui.status(_(b"checking manifests\n"))
 
         filenodes = {}
         subdirnodes = {}
         seen = {}
         label = b"manifest"
         if dir:
             label = dir
             revlogfiles = mf.files()
             storefiles.difference_update(revlogfiles)
             if subdirprogress:  # should be true since we're in a subdirectory
                 subdirprogress.increment()
         if self.refersmf:
             # Do not check manifest if there are only changelog entries with
             # null manifests.
             self._checkrevlog(mf, label, 0)
         progress = ui.makeprogress(
             _(b'checking'), unit=_(b'manifests'), total=len(mf)
         )
         for i in mf:
             if not dir:
                 progress.update(i)
             n = mf.node(i)
             lr = self._checkentry(mf, i, n, seen, mflinkrevs.get(n, []), label)
             if n in mflinkrevs:
                 del mflinkrevs[n]
             elif dir:
                 self._err(
                     lr,
                     _(b"%s not in parent-directory manifest") % short(n),
                     label,
                 )
             else:
                 self._err(lr, _(b"%s not in changesets") % short(n), label)
 
             try:
                 mfdelta = mfl.get(dir, n).readdelta(shallow=True)
                 for f, fn, fl in mfdelta.iterentries():
                     if not f:
                         self._err(lr, _(b"entry without name in manifest"))
                     elif f == b"/dev/null":  # ignore this in very old repos
                         continue
                     fullpath = dir + _normpath(f)
                     if fl == b't':
                         if not match.visitdir(fullpath):
                             continue
                         subdirnodes.setdefault(fullpath + b'/', {}).setdefault(
                             fn, []
                         ).append(lr)
                     else:
                         if not match(fullpath):
                             continue
                         filenodes.setdefault(fullpath, {}).setdefault(fn, lr)
             except Exception as inst:
                 self._exc(lr, _(b"reading delta %s") % short(n), inst, label)
             if self._level >= VERIFY_FULL:
                 try:
                     # Various issues can affect manifest. So we read each full
                     # text from storage. This triggers the checks from the core
                     # code (eg: hash verification, filename are ordered, etc.)
                     mfdelta = mfl.get(dir, n).read()
                 except Exception as inst:
                     self._exc(
                         lr,
                         _(b"reading full manifest %s") % short(n),
                         inst,
                         label,
                     )
 
         if not dir:
             progress.complete()
 
         if self.havemf:
             # since we delete entry in `mflinkrevs` during iteration, any
             # remaining entries are "missing". We need to issue errors for them.
             changesetpairs = [(c, m) for m in mflinkrevs for c in mflinkrevs[m]]
             for c, m in sorted(changesetpairs):
                 if dir:
                     self._err(
                         c,
                         _(
                             b"parent-directory manifest refers to unknown"
                             b" revision %s"
                         )
                         % short(m),
                         label,
                     )
                 else:
                     self._err(
                         c,
                         _(b"changeset refers to unknown revision %s")
                         % short(m),
                         label,
                     )
 
         if not dir and subdirnodes:
             self.ui.status(_(b"checking directory manifests\n"))
             storefiles = set()
             subdirs = set()
             revlogv1 = self.revlogv1
             for f, f2, size in repo.store.datafiles():
                 if not f:
                     self._err(None, _(b"cannot decode filename '%s'") % f2)
                 elif (size > 0 or not revlogv1) and f.startswith(b'meta/'):
                     storefiles.add(_normpath(f))
                     subdirs.add(os.path.dirname(f))
             subdirprogress = ui.makeprogress(
                 _(b'checking'), unit=_(b'manifests'), total=len(subdirs)
             )
 
         for subdir, linkrevs in pycompat.iteritems(subdirnodes):
             subdirfilenodes = self._verifymanifest(
                 linkrevs, subdir, storefiles, subdirprogress
             )
             for f, onefilenodes in pycompat.iteritems(subdirfilenodes):
                 filenodes.setdefault(f, {}).update(onefilenodes)
 
         if not dir and subdirnodes:
             subdirprogress.complete()
             if self.warnorphanstorefiles:
                 for f in sorted(storefiles):
                     self._warn(_(b"warning: orphan data file '%s'") % f)
 
         return filenodes
 
     def _crosscheckfiles(self, filelinkrevs, filenodes):
         repo = self.repo
         ui = self.ui
         ui.status(_(b"crosschecking files in changesets and manifests\n"))
 
         total = len(filelinkrevs) + len(filenodes)
         progress = ui.makeprogress(
             _(b'crosschecking'), unit=_(b'files'), total=total
         )
         if self.havemf:
             for f in sorted(filelinkrevs):
                 progress.increment()
                 if f not in filenodes:
                     lr = filelinkrevs[f][0]
                     self._err(lr, _(b"in changeset but not in manifest"), f)
 
         if self.havecl:
             for f in sorted(filenodes):
                 progress.increment()
                 if f not in filelinkrevs:
                     try:
                         fl = repo.file(f)
                         lr = min([fl.linkrev(fl.rev(n)) for n in filenodes[f]])
                     except Exception:
                         lr = None
                     self._err(lr, _(b"in manifest but not in changeset"), f)
 
         progress.complete()
 
     def _verifyfiles(self, filenodes, filelinkrevs):
         repo = self.repo
         ui = self.ui
         lrugetctx = self.lrugetctx
         revlogv1 = self.revlogv1
         havemf = self.havemf
         ui.status(_(b"checking files\n"))
 
         storefiles = set()
         for f, f2, size in repo.store.datafiles():
             if not f:
                 self._err(None, _(b"cannot decode filename '%s'") % f2)
             elif (size > 0 or not revlogv1) and f.startswith(b'data/'):
                 storefiles.add(_normpath(f))
 
         state = {
             # TODO this assumes revlog storage for changelog.
             b'expectedversion': self.repo.changelog.version & 0xFFFF,
             b'skipflags': self.skipflags,
             # experimental config: censor.policy
             b'erroroncensored': ui.config(b'censor', b'policy') == b'abort',
         }
 
         files = sorted(set(filenodes) | set(filelinkrevs))
         revisions = 0
         progress = ui.makeprogress(
             _(b'checking'), unit=_(b'files'), total=len(files)
         )
         for i, f in enumerate(files):
             progress.update(i, item=f)
             try:
                 linkrevs = filelinkrevs[f]
             except KeyError:
                 # in manifest but not in changelog
                 linkrevs = []
 
             if linkrevs:
                 lr = linkrevs[0]
             else:
                 lr = None
 
             try:
                 fl = repo.file(f)
             except error.StorageError as e:
                 self._err(lr, _(b"broken revlog! (%s)") % e, f)
                 continue
 
             for ff in fl.files():
                 try:
                     storefiles.remove(ff)
                 except KeyError:
                     if self.warnorphanstorefiles:
                         self._warn(
                             _(b" warning: revlog '%s' not in fncache!") % ff
                         )
                         self.fncachewarned = True
 
             if not len(fl) and (self.havecl or self.havemf):
                 self._err(lr, _(b"empty or missing %s") % f)
             else:
                 # Guard against implementations not setting this.
                 state[b'skipread'] = set()
                 for problem in fl.verifyintegrity(state):
                     if problem.node is not None:
                         linkrev = fl.linkrev(fl.rev(problem.node))
                     else:
                         linkrev = None
 
                     if problem.warning:
                         self._warn(problem.warning)
                     elif problem.error:
                         self._err(
                             linkrev if linkrev is not None else lr,
                             problem.error,
                             f,
                         )
                     else:
                         raise error.ProgrammingError(
                             b'problem instance does not set warning or error '
                             b'attribute: %s' % problem.msg
                         )
 
             seen = {}
             for i in fl:
                 revisions += 1
                 n = fl.node(i)
                 lr = self._checkentry(fl, i, n, seen, linkrevs, f)
                 if f in filenodes:
                     if havemf and n not in filenodes[f]:
                         self._err(lr, _(b"%s not in manifests") % (short(n)), f)
                     else:
                         del filenodes[f][n]
 
                 if n in state[b'skipread']:
                     continue
 
                 # check renames
                 try:
-                    # This requires resolving fulltext (at least on revlogs). We
-                    # may want ``verifyintegrity()`` to pass a set of nodes with
+                    # This requires resolving fulltext (at least on revlogs,
+                    # though not with LFS revisions). We may want
+                    # ``verifyintegrity()`` to pass a set of nodes with
                     # rename metadata as an optimization.
                     rp = fl.renamed(n)
                     if rp:
                         if lr is not None and ui.verbose:
                             ctx = lrugetctx(lr)
                             if not any(rp[0] in pctx for pctx in ctx.parents()):
                                 self._warn(
                                     _(
                                         b"warning: copy source of '%s' not"
                                         b" in parents of %s"
                                     )
                                     % (f, ctx)
                                 )
                         fl2 = repo.file(rp[0])
                         if not len(fl2):
                             self._err(
                                 lr,
                                 _(
                                     b"empty or missing copy source revlog "
                                     b"%s:%s"
                                 )
                                 % (rp[0], short(rp[1])),
                                 f,
                             )
                         elif rp[1] == nullid:
                             ui.note(
                                 _(
                                     b"warning: %s@%s: copy source"
                                     b" revision is nullid %s:%s\n"
                                 )
                                 % (f, lr, rp[0], short(rp[1]))
                             )
                         else:
                             fl2.rev(rp[1])
                 except Exception as inst:
                     self._exc(
                         lr, _(b"checking rename of %s") % short(n), inst, f
                     )
 
             # cross-check
             if f in filenodes:
                 fns = [(v, k) for k, v in pycompat.iteritems(filenodes[f])]
                 for lr, node in sorted(fns):
                     self._err(
                         lr,
                         _(b"manifest refers to unknown revision %s")
                         % short(node),
                         f,
                     )
         progress.complete()
 
         if self.warnorphanstorefiles:
             for f in sorted(storefiles):
                 self._warn(_(b"warning: orphan data file '%s'") % f)
 
         return len(files), revisions