comments: allow submitting id of comment which submitted comment resolved.

- use common template for inject forms
- cleanup of JS models, bind class of Form into the form itself

rhodecode/config/routing.py

@@ -694,8 +694,8 b' def make_map(config):'
                  requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS, jsroute=True)
 
     rmap.connect('repo_refs_data', '/{repo_name}/refs-data',
-                 controller='summary', action='repo_refs_data', jsroute=True,
-                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS)
+                 controller='summary', action='repo_refs_data',
+                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS, jsroute=True)
     rmap.connect('repo_refs_changelog_data', '/{repo_name}/refs-data-changelog',
                  controller='summary', action='repo_refs_changelog_data',
                  requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS, jsroute=True)
@@ -704,9 +704,9 b' def make_map(config):'
                  jsroute=True, requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS)
 
     rmap.connect('changeset_home', '/{repo_name}/changeset/{revision}',
-                 controller='changeset', revision='tip', jsroute=True,
+                 controller='changeset', revision='tip',
                  conditions={'function': check_repo},
-                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS)
+                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS, jsroute=True)
     rmap.connect('changeset_children', '/{repo_name}/changeset_children/{revision}',
                  controller='changeset', revision='tip', action='changeset_children',
                  conditions={'function': check_repo},
@@ -923,7 +923,7 b' def make_map(config):'
                  controller='pullrequests',
                  action='show', conditions={'function': check_repo,
                                             'method': ['GET']},
-                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS)
+                 requirements=URL_NAME_REQUIREMENTS, jsroute=True)
 
     rmap.connect('pullrequest_update',
                  '/{repo_name}/pull-request/{pull_request_id}',

rhodecode/controllers/pullrequests.py

@@ -904,6 +904,8 b' class PullrequestsController(BaseRepoCon'
         status = request.POST.get('changeset_status', None)
         text = request.POST.get('text')
         comment_type = request.POST.get('comment_type')
+        resolves_comment_id = request.POST.get('resolves_comment_id')
+
         if status and '_closed' in status:
             close_pr = True
             status = status.replace('_closed', '')
@@ -936,7 +938,8 b' class PullrequestsController(BaseRepoCon'
             status_change_type=(status
                                 if status and allowed_to_change_status else None),
             closing_pr=close_pr,
-            comment_type=comment_type
+            comment_type=comment_type,
+            resolves_comment_id=resolves_comment_id
         )
 
         if allowed_to_change_status:

rhodecode/model/comment.py

@@ -84,9 +84,10 b' class CommentsModel(BaseModel):'
         return global_renderer
 
     def create(self, text, repo, user, commit_id=None, pull_request=None,
-               f_path=None, line_no=None, status_change=None, comment_type=None,
-               status_change_type=None, closing_pr=False,
-               send_email=True, renderer=None):
+               f_path=None, line_no=None, status_change=None,
+               status_change_type=None, comment_type=None,
+               resolves_comment_id=None, closing_pr=False, send_email=True,
+               renderer=None):
         """
         Creates new comment for commit or pull request.
         IF status_change is not none this comment is associated with a
@@ -113,6 +114,8 b' class CommentsModel(BaseModel):'
         if not renderer:
             renderer = self._get_renderer()
 
+        repo = self._get_repo(repo)
+        user = self._get_user(user)
 
         schema = comment_schema.CommentSchema()
         validated_kwargs = schema.deserialize(dict(
@@ -121,15 +124,12 b' class CommentsModel(BaseModel):'
             comment_file=f_path,
             comment_line=line_no,
             renderer_type=renderer,
-            status_change=status_change,
-
-            repo=repo,
-            user=user,
+            status_change=status_change_type,
+            resolves_comment_id=resolves_comment_id,
+            repo=repo.repo_id,
+            user=user.user_id,
         ))
 
-        repo = self._get_repo(validated_kwargs['repo'])
-        user = self._get_user(validated_kwargs['user'])
-
         comment = ChangesetComment()
         comment.renderer = validated_kwargs['renderer_type']
         comment.text = validated_kwargs['comment_body']
@@ -139,6 +139,8 b' class CommentsModel(BaseModel):'
 
         comment.repo = repo
         comment.author = user
+        comment.resolved_comment = self.__get_commit_comment(
+            validated_kwargs['resolves_comment_id'])
 
         pull_request_id = pull_request
 

rhodecode/model/db.py

@@ -2917,7 +2917,7 b' class ChangesetComment(Base, BaseModel):'
 
     comment_type = Column('comment_type',  Unicode(128), nullable=True, default=COMMENT_TYPE_NOTE)
     resolved_comment_id = Column('resolved_comment_id', Integer(), ForeignKey('changeset_comments.comment_id'), nullable=True)
-    resolved_comment = relationship('ChangesetComment', remote_side=comment_id)
+    resolved_comment = relationship('ChangesetComment', remote_side=comment_id, backref='resolved_by')
     author = relationship('User', lazy='joined')
     repo = relationship('Repository')
     status_change = relationship('ChangesetStatus', cascade="all, delete, delete-orphan")
@@ -2959,6 +2959,10 b' class ChangesetComment(Base, BaseModel):'
         """
         return self.outdated and self.pull_request_version_id != version
 
+    @property
+    def resolved(self):
+        return self.resolved_by[0] if self.resolved_by else None
+
     def get_index_version(self, versions):
         return self.get_index_from_version(
             self.pull_request_version_id, versions)

rhodecode/model/validation_schema/schemas/comment_schema.py

@@ -53,18 +53,22 b" comment_types = ['note', 'todo']"
 
 
 class CommentSchema(colander.MappingSchema):
-    from rhodecode.model.db import ChangesetComment
+    from rhodecode.model.db import ChangesetComment, ChangesetStatus
 
     comment_body = colander.SchemaNode(colander.String())
     comment_type = colander.SchemaNode(
         colander.String(),
-        validator=colander.OneOf(ChangesetComment.COMMENT_TYPES))
+        validator=colander.OneOf(ChangesetComment.COMMENT_TYPES),
+        missing=ChangesetComment.COMMENT_TYPE_NOTE)
 
     comment_file = colander.SchemaNode(colander.String(), missing=None)
     comment_line = colander.SchemaNode(colander.String(), missing=None)
-    status_change = colander.SchemaNode(colander.String(), missing=None)
+    status_change = colander.SchemaNode(
+        colander.String(), missing=None,
+        validator=colander.OneOf([x[0] for x in ChangesetStatus.STATUSES]))
     renderer_type = colander.SchemaNode(colander.String())
 
-    # do those ?
+    resolves_comment_id = colander.SchemaNode(colander.Integer(), missing=None)
+
     user = colander.SchemaNode(types.StrOrIntType())
     repo = colander.SchemaNode(types.StrOrIntType())

rhodecode/public/css/comments.less

@@ -66,6 +66,7 b' tr.inline-comments div {'
     white-space: nowrap;
 
     text-transform: uppercase;
+    min-width: 40px;
 
     &.todo {
         color: @color5;
@@ -366,7 +367,7 b' form.comment-form {'
         display: inline-block;
     }
 
-    .comment-button .comment-button-input {
+    .comment-button-input {
         margin-right: 0;
     }
 

rhodecode/public/js/rhodecode/routes.js

@@ -37,6 +37,7 b' function registerRCRoutes() {'
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request/new', ['repo_name']);
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest_repo_refs', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request/refs/%(target_repo_name)s', ['repo_name', 'target_repo_name']);
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest_repo_destinations', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request/repo-destinations', ['repo_name']);
+    pyroutes.register('pullrequest_show', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request/%(pull_request_id)s', ['repo_name', 'pull_request_id']);
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest_update', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request/%(pull_request_id)s', ['repo_name', 'pull_request_id']);
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest_show_all', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request', ['repo_name']);
     pyroutes.register('pullrequest_comment', '/%(repo_name)s/pull-request-comment/%(pull_request_id)s', ['repo_name', 'pull_request_id']);

rhodecode/public/js/src/rhodecode/comments.js

@@ -79,7 +79,7 b' var bindToggleButtons = function() {'
 };
 
 var linkifyComments = function(comments) {
-  /* TODO: dan: remove this - it should no longer needed */
+  /* TODO: marcink: remove this - it should no longer needed */
   for (var i = 0; i < comments.length; i++) {
     var comment_id = $(comments[i]).data('comment-id');
     var prev_comment_id = $(comments[i - 1]).data('comment-id');
@@ -96,6 +96,8 b' var linkifyComments = function(comments)'
       $('#next_c_' + comment_id + " a.arrow_comment_link").attr(
           'href', '#comment-' + next_comment_id).removeClass('disabled');
     }
+    /* TODO(marcink): end removal here */
+
     // place a first link to the total counter
     if (i === 0) {
       $('#inline-comments-counter').attr('href', '#comment-' + comment_id);
@@ -106,10 +108,23 b' var linkifyComments = function(comments)'
 
 
 /* Comment form for main and inline comments */
-var CommentForm = (function() {
+
+(function(mod) {
+  if (typeof exports == "object" && typeof module == "object") // CommonJS
+    module.exports = mod();
+  else // Plain browser env
+    (this || window).CommentForm = mod();
+
+})(function() {
     "use strict";
 
-    function CommentForm(formElement, commitId, pullRequestId, lineNo, initAutocompleteActions) {
+    function CommentForm(formElement, commitId, pullRequestId, lineNo, initAutocompleteActions, resolvesCommentId) {
+        if (!(this instanceof CommentForm)) {
+            return new CommentForm(formElement, commitId, pullRequestId, lineNo, initAutocompleteActions, resolvesCommentId);
+        }
+
+        // bind the element instance to our Form
+        $(formElement).get(0).CommentForm = this;
 
         this.withLineNo = function(selector) {
             var lineNo = this.lineNo;
@@ -135,6 +150,9 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
         this.cancelButton = this.withLineNo('#cancel-btn');
         this.commentType = this.withLineNo('#comment_type');
 
+        this.resolvesId = null;
+        this.resolvesActionId = null;
+
         this.cmBox = this.withLineNo('#text');
         this.cm = initCommentBoxCodeMirror(this.cmBox, this.initAutocompleteActions);
 
@@ -147,17 +165,38 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
         this.previewUrl = pyroutes.url('changeset_comment_preview',
             {'repo_name': templateContext.repo_name});
 
-        // based on commitId, or pullReuqestId decide where do we submit
+        if (resolvesCommentId){
+            this.resolvesId = '#resolve_comment_{0}'.format(resolvesCommentId);
+            this.resolvesActionId = '#resolve_comment_action_{0}'.format(resolvesCommentId);
+            $(this.commentType).prop('disabled', true);
+            $(this.commentType).addClass('disabled');
+
+            var resolvedInfo = (
+                '<li class="">' +
+                '<input type="hidden" id="resolve_comment_{0}" name="resolve_comment_{0}" value="{0}">' +
+                '<button id="resolve_comment_action_{0}" class="resolve-text btn btn-sm" onclick="return Rhodecode.comments.submitResolution({0})">{1} #{0}</button>' +
+                '</li>'
+            ).format(resolvesCommentId, _gettext('resolve comment'));
+            $(resolvedInfo).insertAfter($(this.commentType).parent());
+        }
+
+        // based on commitId, or pullRequestId decide where do we submit
         // out data
         if (this.commitId){
             this.submitUrl = pyroutes.url('changeset_comment',
                 {'repo_name': templateContext.repo_name,
                  'revision': this.commitId});
+            this.selfUrl = pyroutes.url('changeset_home',
+                {'repo_name': templateContext.repo_name,
+                 'revision': this.commitId});
 
         } else if (this.pullRequestId) {
             this.submitUrl = pyroutes.url('pullrequest_comment',
                 {'repo_name': templateContext.repo_name,
                  'pull_request_id': this.pullRequestId});
+            this.selfUrl = pyroutes.url('pullrequest_show',
+                {'repo_name': templateContext.repo_name,
+                 'pull_request_id': this.pullRequestId});
 
         } else {
             throw new Error(
@@ -168,6 +207,13 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
             return this.cm
         };
 
+        this.setPlaceholder = function(placeholder) {
+            var cm = this.getCmInstance();
+            if (cm){
+                cm.setOption('placeholder', placeholder);
+            }
+        };
+
         var self = this;
 
         this.getCommentStatus = function() {
@@ -176,6 +222,15 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
         this.getCommentType = function() {
           return $(this.submitForm).find(this.commentType).val();
         };
+
+        this.getResolvesId = function() {
+            return $(this.submitForm).find(this.resolvesId).val() || null;
+        };
+        this.markCommentResolved = function(resolvedCommentId){
+            $('#comment-label-{0}'.format(resolvedCommentId)).find('.resolved').show();
+            $('#comment-label-{0}'.format(resolvedCommentId)).find('.resolve').hide();
+        };
+
         this.isAllowedToSubmit = function() {
           return !$(this.submitButton).prop('disabled');
         };
@@ -205,12 +260,12 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
             });
             $(this.submitForm).find(this.statusChange).on('change', function() {
                 var status = self.getCommentStatus();
-                if (status && !self.lineNo) {
+                if (status && self.lineNo == 'general') {
                     $(self.submitButton).prop('disabled', false);
                 }
-                //todo, fix this name
+
                 var placeholderText = _gettext('Comment text will be set automatically based on currently selected status ({0}) ...').format(status);
-                self.cm.setOption('placeholder', placeholderText);
+                self.setPlaceholder(placeholderText)
             })
         };
 
@@ -260,6 +315,7 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
             var text = self.cm.getValue();
             var status = self.getCommentStatus();
             var commentType = self.getCommentType();
+            var resolvesCommentId = self.getResolvesId();
 
             if (text === "" && !status) {
                 return;
@@ -275,7 +331,9 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
                 'comment_type': commentType,
                 'csrf_token': CSRF_TOKEN
             };
-
+            if (resolvesCommentId){
+                postData['resolves_comment_id'] = resolvesCommentId;
+            }
             var submitSuccessCallback = function(o) {
                 if (status) {
                     location.reload(true);
@@ -284,10 +342,15 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
                     self.resetCommentFormState();
                     bindDeleteCommentButtons();
                     timeagoActivate();
+
+                    //mark visually which comment was resolved
+                    if (resolvesCommentId) {
+                        this.markCommentResolved(resolvesCommentId);
+                    }
                 }
             };
             var submitFailCallback = function(){
-                self.resetCommentFormState(text)
+                self.resetCommentFormState(text);
             };
             self.submitAjaxPOST(
                 self.submitUrl, postData, submitSuccessCallback, submitFailCallback);
@@ -367,7 +430,7 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
 
             var postData = {
                 'text': text,
-                'renderer': DEFAULT_RENDERER,
+                'renderer': templateContext.visual.default_renderer,
                 'csrf_token': CSRF_TOKEN
             };
 
@@ -404,15 +467,17 b' var CommentForm = (function() {'
     }
 
     return CommentForm;
-})();
+});
 
-var CommentsController = function() { /* comments controller */
+/* comments controller */
+var CommentsController = function() {
+  var mainComment = '#text';
   var self = this;
 
   this.cancelComment = function(node) {
       var $node = $(node);
       var $td = $node.closest('td');
-      $node.closest('.comment-inline-form').removeClass('comment-inline-form-open');
+      $node.closest('.comment-inline-form').remove();
       return false;
   };
 
@@ -530,7 +595,8 b' var CommentsController = function() { /*'
     $node.closest('tr').toggleClass('hide-line-comments');
   };
 
-  this.createComment = function(node) {
+  this.createComment = function(node, resolutionComment) {
+      var resolvesCommentId = resolutionComment || null;
       var $node = $(node);
       var $td = $node.closest('td');
       var $form = $td.find('.comment-inline-form');
@@ -556,14 +622,16 b' var CommentsController = function() { /*'
 
           var pullRequestId = templateContext.pull_request_data.pull_request_id;
           var commitId = templateContext.commit_data.commit_id;
-          var _form = $form[0];
-          var commentForm = new CommentForm(_form, commitId, pullRequestId, lineno, false);
+          var _form = $($form[0]).find('form');
+
+          var commentForm = new CommentForm(_form, commitId, pullRequestId, lineno, false, resolvesCommentId);
           var cm = commentForm.getCmInstance();
 
           // set a CUSTOM submit handler for inline comments.
           commentForm.setHandleFormSubmit(function(o) {
             var text = commentForm.cm.getValue();
             var commentType = commentForm.getCommentType();
+            var resolvesCommentId = commentForm.getResolvesId();
 
             if (text === "") {
               return;
@@ -589,6 +657,10 b' var CommentsController = function() { /*'
                 'comment_type': commentType,
                 'csrf_token': CSRF_TOKEN
             };
+            if (resolvesCommentId){
+                postData['resolves_comment_id'] = resolvesCommentId;
+            }
+
             var submitSuccessCallback = function(json_data) {
               $form.remove();
               try {
@@ -598,6 +670,11 b' var CommentsController = function() { /*'
 
                 $comments.find('.cb-comment-add-button').before(html);
 
+                //mark visually which comment was resolved
+                if (resolvesCommentId) {
+                    commentForm.markCommentResolved(resolvesCommentId);
+                }
+
               } catch (e) {
                 console.error(e);
               }
@@ -616,26 +693,81 b' var CommentsController = function() { /*'
                 commentForm.submitUrl, postData, submitSuccessCallback, submitFailCallback);
           });
 
+          if (resolvesCommentId){
+              var placeholderText = _gettext('Leave a comment, or click resolve button to resolve TODO comment #{0}').format(resolvesCommentId);
+
+          } else {
+              var placeholderText = _gettext('Leave a comment on line {0}.').format(lineno);
+          }
+
           setTimeout(function() {
               // callbacks
               if (cm !== undefined) {
-                  cm.setOption('placeholder', _gettext('Leave a comment on line {0}.').format(lineno));
+                  commentForm.setPlaceholder(placeholderText);
                   cm.focus();
                   cm.refresh();
               }
           }, 10);
 
-            $.Topic('/ui/plugins/code/comment_form_built').prepareOrPublish({
-                form: _form,
-                parent: $td[0],
-                lineno: lineno,
-                f_path: f_path}
-            );
+          $.Topic('/ui/plugins/code/comment_form_built').prepareOrPublish({
+              form: _form,
+              parent: $td[0],
+              lineno: lineno,
+              f_path: f_path}
+          );
+
+          // trigger hash
+          if (resolvesCommentId){
+            var resolveAction = $(commentForm.resolvesActionId);
+            setTimeout(function() {
+                $('body, html').animate({ scrollTop: resolveAction.offset().top }, 10);
+            }, 100);
+          }
       }
 
       $form.addClass('comment-inline-form-open');
   };
 
+  this.createResolutionComment = function(commentId){
+    // hide the trigger text
+    $('#resolve-comment-{0}'.format(commentId)).hide();
+
+    var comment = $('#comment-'+commentId);
+    var commentData = comment.data();
+
+    if (commentData.commentInline) {
+        var resolutionComment = true;
+        this.createComment(comment, commentId)
+    } else {
+
+        this.createComment(comment, commentId)
+
+        console.log('TODO')
+        console.log(commentId)
+    }
+
+    return false;
+  };
+
+  this.submitResolution = function(commentId){
+    var form = $('#resolve_comment_{0}'.format(commentId)).closest('form');
+    var commentForm = form.get(0).CommentForm;
+
+    var cm = commentForm.getCmInstance();
+    var renderer = templateContext.visual.default_renderer;
+    if (renderer == 'rst'){
+        var commentUrl = '`#{0} <{1}#comment-{0}>`_'.format(commentId, commentForm.selfUrl);
+    } else if (renderer == 'markdown') {
+        var commentUrl = '[#{0}]({1}#comment-{0})'.format(commentId, commentForm.selfUrl);
+    } else {
+        var commentUrl = '{1}#comment-{0}'.format(commentId, commentForm.selfUrl);
+    }
+
+    cm.setValue(_gettext('TODO from comment {0} was fixed.').format(commentUrl));
+    form.submit();
+    return false;
+  };
+
   this.renderInlineComments = function(file_comments) {
     show_add_button = typeof show_add_button !== 'undefined' ? show_add_button : true;
 

rhodecode/templates/changeset/changeset_file_comment.mako

@@ -15,12 +15,33 b''
        id="comment-${comment.comment_id}"
        line="${comment.line_no}"
        data-comment-id="${comment.comment_id}"
+       data-comment-type="${comment.comment_type}"
+       data-comment-inline=${h.json.dumps(inline)}
        style="${'display: none;' if outdated_at_ver else ''}">
 
       <div class="meta">
-          <div class="comment-type-label tooltip">
-              <div class="comment-label ${comment.comment_type or 'note'}">
-                ${comment.comment_type or 'note'}
+          <div class="comment-type-label">
+              <div class="comment-label ${comment.comment_type or 'note'}" id="comment-label-${comment.comment_id}">
+              % if comment.comment_type == 'todo':
+                  % if comment.resolved:
+                      <div class="resolved tooltip" title="${_('Resolved by comment #{}').format(comment.resolved.comment_id)}">
+                          <a href="#comment-${comment.resolved.comment_id}">${comment.comment_type}</a>
+                      </div>
+                  % else:
+                      <div class="resolved tooltip" style="display: none">
+                          <span>${comment.comment_type}</span>
+                      </div>
+                      <div class="resolve tooltip" onclick="return Rhodecode.comments.createResolutionComment(${comment.comment_id});" title="${_('Click to resolve this comment')}">
+                        ${comment.comment_type}
+                      </div>
+                  % endif
+              % else:
+                  % if comment.resolved_comment:
+                    fix
+                  % else:
+                    ${comment.comment_type or 'note'}
+                  % endif
+              % endif
               </div>
           </div>
 
@@ -120,6 +141,7 b''
 
   </div>
 </%def>
+
 ## generate main comments
 <%def name="generate_comments(include_pull_request=False, is_pull_request=False)">
   <div id="comments">
@@ -137,16 +159,10 b''
   </div>
 </%def>
 
-## MAIN COMMENT FORM
+
 <%def name="comments(post_url, cur_status, is_pull_request=False, is_compare=False, change_status=True, form_extras=None)">
 
-%if is_compare:
-  <% form_id = "comments_form_compare" %>
-%else:
-  <% form_id = "comments_form" %>
-%endif
-
-
+## merge status, and merge action
 %if is_pull_request:
 <div class="pull-request-merge">
     %if c.allowed_to_merge:
@@ -168,6 +184,7 b''
     %endif
 </div>
 %endif
+
 <div class="comments">
     <%
       if is_pull_request:
@@ -177,78 +194,28 b''
       else:
         placeholder = _('Leave a comment on this Commit.')
     %>
+
     % if c.rhodecode_user.username != h.DEFAULT_USER:
     <div class="comment-form ac">
-        ${h.secure_form(post_url, id_=form_id)}
-        <div class="comment-area">
-            <div class="comment-area-header">
-                <ul class="nav-links clearfix">
-                    <li class="active">
-                        <a href="#edit-btn" tabindex="-1" id="edit-btn">${_('Write')}</a>
-                    </li>
-                    <li class="">
-                        <a href="#preview-btn" tabindex="-1" id="preview-btn">${_('Preview')}</a>
-                    </li>
-                    <li class="pull-right">
-                        <select class="comment-type" id="comment_type" name="comment_type">
-                            % for val in c.visual.comment_types:
-                                <option value="${val}">${val.upper()}</option>
-                            % endfor
-                        </select>
-                    </li>
-                </ul>
-            </div>
-
-            <div class="comment-area-write" style="display: block;">
-                <div id="edit-container">
-                    <textarea id="text" name="text" class="comment-block-ta ac-input"></textarea>
-                </div>
-                <div id="preview-container" class="clearfix" style="display: none;">
-                    <div id="preview-box" class="preview-box"></div>
-                </div>
-            </div>
+        ## inject form here
+        ${comment_form(form_type='general', form_id='general_comment', lineno_id='general', review_statuses=c.commit_statuses, form_extras=form_extras)}
+    </div>
+    <script type="text/javascript">
+        // init active elements of commentForm
+        var commitId = templateContext.commit_data.commit_id;
+        var pullRequestId = templateContext.pull_request_data.pull_request_id;
+        var lineNo = 'general';
+        var resolvesCommitId = null;
 
-            <div class="comment-area-footer">
-                <div class="toolbar">
-                    <div class="toolbar-text">
-                      ${(_('Comments parsed using %s syntax with %s support.') % (
-                             ('<a href="%s">%s</a>' % (h.url('%s_help' % c.visual.default_renderer), c.visual.default_renderer.upper())),
-                               ('<span  class="tooltip" title="%s">@mention</span>' % _('Use @username inside this text to send notification to this RhodeCode user'))
-                           )
-                        )|n}
-                    </div>
-                </div>
-            </div>
-        </div>
+        var mainCommentForm = new CommentForm(
+                "#general_comment", commitId, pullRequestId, lineNo, true, resolvesCommitId);
+        mainCommentForm.setPlaceholder("${placeholder}");
+        mainCommentForm.initStatusChangeSelector();
+    </script>
 
-        <div id="comment_form_extras">
-        %if form_extras and isinstance(form_extras, (list, tuple)):
-            % for form_ex_el in form_extras:
-                ${form_ex_el|n}
-            % endfor
-        %endif
-        </div>
-        <div class="comment-footer">
-          %if change_status:
-          <div class="status_box">
-              <select id="change_status" name="changeset_status">
-                  <option></option> # Placeholder
-                  %for status,lbl in c.commit_statuses:
-                  <option value="${status}" data-status="${status}">${lbl}</option>
-                      %if is_pull_request and change_status and status in ('approved', 'rejected'):
-                          <option value="${status}_closed" data-status="${status}">${lbl} & ${_('Closed')}</option>
-                      %endif
-                  %endfor
-              </select>
-          </div>
-          %endif
-          <div class="action-buttons">
-              <div class="comment-button">${h.submit('save', _('Comment'), class_="btn btn-success comment-button-input")}</div>
-          </div>
-        </div>
-          ${h.end_form()}
-    </div>
+
     % else:
+    ## form state when not logged in
     <div class="comment-form ac">
 
         <div class="comment-area">
@@ -289,22 +256,98 b''
     </div>
     % endif
 
+    <script type="text/javascript">
+        bindToggleButtons();
+    </script>
 </div>
+</%def>
+
+
+<%def name="comment_form(form_type, form_id='', lineno_id='{1}', review_statuses=None, form_extras=None)">
+  ## comment injected based on assumption that user is logged in
+
+  <form ${'id="{}"'.format(form_id) if form_id else '' |n} action="#" method="GET">
 
-<script>
-    // init active elements of commentForm
-    var commitId = templateContext.commit_data.commit_id;
-    var pullRequestId = templateContext.pull_request_data.pull_request_id;
-    var lineNo;
+    <div class="comment-area">
+        <div class="comment-area-header">
+            <ul class="nav-links clearfix">
+                <li class="active">
+                    <a href="#edit-btn" tabindex="-1" id="edit-btn_${lineno_id}">${_('Write')}</a>
+                </li>
+                <li class="">
+                    <a href="#preview-btn" tabindex="-1" id="preview-btn_${lineno_id}">${_('Preview')}</a>
+                </li>
+                <li class="pull-right">
+                    <select class="comment-type" id="comment_type_${lineno_id}" name="comment_type">
+                        % for val in c.visual.comment_types:
+                            <option value="${val}">${val.upper()}</option>
+                        % endfor
+                    </select>
+                </li>
+            </ul>
+        </div>
+
+        <div class="comment-area-write" style="display: block;">
+            <div id="edit-container_${lineno_id}">
+                <textarea id="text_${lineno_id}" name="text" class="comment-block-ta ac-input"></textarea>
+            </div>
+            <div id="preview-container_${lineno_id}" class="clearfix" style="display: none;">
+                <div id="preview-box_${lineno_id}" class="preview-box"></div>
+            </div>
+        </div>
 
-    var mainCommentForm = new CommentForm(
-            "#${form_id}", commitId, pullRequestId, lineNo, true);
+        <div class="comment-area-footer">
+            <div class="toolbar">
+                <div class="toolbar-text">
+                  ${(_('Comments parsed using %s syntax with %s support.') % (
+                         ('<a href="%s">%s</a>' % (h.url('%s_help' % c.visual.default_renderer), c.visual.default_renderer.upper())),
+                           ('<span  class="tooltip" title="%s">@mention</span>' % _('Use @username inside this text to send notification to this RhodeCode user'))
+                       )
+                    )|n}
+                </div>
+            </div>
+        </div>
+    </div>
+
+    <div class="comment-footer">
 
-    if (mainCommentForm.cm){
-        mainCommentForm.cm.setOption('placeholder', "${placeholder}");
-    }
+        % if review_statuses:
+        <div class="status_box">
+          <select id="change_status" name="changeset_status">
+              <option></option> ## Placeholder
+              % for status, lbl in review_statuses:
+              <option value="${status}" data-status="${status}">${lbl}</option>
+                  %if is_pull_request and change_status and status in ('approved', 'rejected'):
+                      <option value="${status}_closed" data-status="${status}">${lbl} & ${_('Closed')}</option>
+                  %endif
+              % endfor
+          </select>
+        </div>
+        % endif
 
-    mainCommentForm.initStatusChangeSelector();
-    bindToggleButtons();
-</script>
-</%def>
+        ## inject extra inputs into the form
+        % if form_extras and isinstance(form_extras, (list, tuple)):
+            <div id="comment_form_extras">
+                % for form_ex_el in form_extras:
+                    ${form_ex_el|n}
+                % endfor
+            </div>
+        % endif
+
+        <div class="action-buttons">
+            ## inline for has a file, and line-number together with cancel hide button.
+            % if form_type == 'inline':
+                <input type="hidden" name="f_path" value="{0}">
+                <input type="hidden" name="line" value="${lineno_id}">
+                <button type="button" class="cb-comment-cancel" onclick="return Rhodecode.comments.cancelComment(this);">
+                ${_('Cancel')}
+                </button>
+            % endif
+            ${h.submit('save', _('Comment'), class_='btn btn-success comment-button-input')}
+
+        </div>
+    </div>
+
+  </form>
+
+</%def>
  No newline at end of file

rhodecode/templates/codeblocks/diffs.mako

@@ -1,3 +1,5 b''
+<%namespace name="commentblock" file="/changeset/changeset_file_comment.mako"/>
+
 <%def name="diff_line_anchor(filename, line, type)"><%
 return '%s_%s_%i' % (h.safeid(filename), type, line)
 %></%def>
@@ -60,59 +62,8 b" return h.url('', **new_args)"
     <div class="comment-inline-form ac">
 
     %if c.rhodecode_user.username != h.DEFAULT_USER:
-        ${h.form('#', method='get')}
-        <div class="comment-area">
-            <div class="comment-area-header">
-                <ul class="nav-links clearfix">
-                    <li class="active">
-                        <a href="#edit-btn" tabindex="-1" id="edit-btn_{1}">${_('Write')}</a>
-                    </li>
-                    <li class="">
-                        <a href="#preview-btn" tabindex="-1" id="preview-btn_{1}">${_('Preview')}</a>
-                    </li>
-                    <li class="pull-right">
-                        <select class="comment-type" id="comment_type_{1}" name="comment_type">
-                            % for val in c.visual.comment_types:
-                                <option value="${val}">${val.upper()}</option>
-                            % endfor
-                        </select>
-                    </li>
-                </ul>
-            </div>
-
-            <div class="comment-area-write" style="display: block;">
-                <div id="edit-container_{1}">
-                    <textarea id="text_{1}" name="text" class="comment-block-ta ac-input"></textarea>
-                </div>
-                <div id="preview-container_{1}" class="clearfix" style="display: none;">
-                    <div id="preview-box_{1}" class="preview-box"></div>
-                </div>
-            </div>
-
-            <div class="comment-area-footer">
-                <div class="toolbar">
-                    <div class="toolbar-text">
-                      ${(_('Comments parsed using %s syntax with %s support.') % (
-                             ('<a href="%s">%s</a>' % (h.url('%s_help' % c.visual.default_renderer), c.visual.default_renderer.upper())),
-                               ('<span  class="tooltip" title="%s">@mention</span>' % _('Use @username inside this text to send notification to this RhodeCode user'))
-                           )
-                        )|n}
-                    </div>
-                </div>
-            </div>
-        </div>
-
-        <div class="comment-footer">
-          <div class="action-buttons">
-            <input type="hidden" name="f_path" value="{0}">
-            <input type="hidden" name="line" value="{1}">
-               <button type="button" class="cb-comment-cancel" onclick="return Rhodecode.comments.cancelComment(this);">
-                ${_('Cancel')}
-               </button>
-               ${h.submit('save', _('Comment'), class_='btn btn-success save-inline-form')}
-          </div>
-        ${h.end_form()}
-      </div>
+        ## render template for inline comments
+        ${commentblock.comment_form(form_type='inline')}
     %else:
         ${h.form('', class_='inline-form comment-form-login', method='get')}
         <div class="pull-left">
@@ -521,7 +472,6 b' from rhodecode.lib.diffs import NEW_FILE'
 </%def>
 
 
-<%namespace name="commentblock" file="/changeset/changeset_file_comment.mako"/>
 <%def name="inline_comments_container(comments)">
 <div class="inline-comments">
     %for comment in comments: