debugrevspec: add option to verify optimized result

This provides a convenient way to diff "hg debugrevspec" outputs generated
with/without --no-optimized option.

mercurial/commands.py

@@ -3516,6 +3516,7 b' def debugrevlog(ui, repo, file_=None, **'
      ('p', 'show-stage', [],
       _('print parsed tree at the given stage'), _('NAME')),
      ('', 'no-optimized', False, _('evaluate tree without optimization')),
+     ('', 'verify-optimized', False, _('verify optimized result')),
      ],
     ('REVSPEC'))
 def debugrevspec(ui, repo, expr, **opts):
@@ -3523,6 +3524,9 b' def debugrevspec(ui, repo, expr, **opts)'
 
     Use -p/--show-stage option to print the parsed tree at the given stages.
     Use -p all to print tree at every stage.
+
+    Use --verify-optimized to compare the optimized result with the unoptimized
+    one. Returns 1 if the optimized result differs.
     """
     stages = [
         ('parsed', lambda tree: tree),
@@ -3533,6 +3537,9 b' def debugrevspec(ui, repo, expr, **opts)'
     ]
     if opts['no_optimized']:
         stages = stages[:-1]
+    if opts['verify_optimized'] and opts['no_optimized']:
+        raise error.Abort(_('cannot use --verify-optimized with '
+                            '--no-optimized'))
     stagenames = set(n for n, f in stages)
 
     showalways = set()
@@ -3553,16 +3560,42 b' def debugrevspec(ui, repo, expr, **opts)'
                 raise error.Abort(_('invalid stage name: %s') % n)
         showalways.update(opts['show_stage'])
 
+    treebystage = {}
     printedtree = None
     tree = revset.parse(expr, lookup=repo.__contains__)
     for n, f in stages:
-        tree = f(tree)
+        treebystage[n] = tree = f(tree)
         if n in showalways or (n in showchanged and tree != printedtree):
             if opts['show_stage'] or n != 'parsed':
                 ui.write(("* %s:\n") % n)
             ui.write(revset.prettyformat(tree), "\n")
             printedtree = tree
 
+    if opts['verify_optimized']:
+        arevs = revset.makematcher(treebystage['analyzed'])(repo)
+        brevs = revset.makematcher(treebystage['optimized'])(repo)
+        if ui.verbose:
+            ui.note(("* analyzed set:\n"), revset.prettyformatset(arevs), "\n")
+            ui.note(("* optimized set:\n"), revset.prettyformatset(brevs), "\n")
+        arevs = list(arevs)
+        brevs = list(brevs)
+        if arevs == brevs:
+            return 0
+        ui.write(('--- analyzed\n'), label='diff.file_a')
+        ui.write(('+++ optimized\n'), label='diff.file_b')
+        sm = difflib.SequenceMatcher(None, arevs, brevs)
+        for tag, alo, ahi, blo, bhi in sm.get_opcodes():
+            if tag in ('delete', 'replace'):
+                for c in arevs[alo:ahi]:
+                    ui.write('-%s\n' % c, label='diff.deleted')
+            if tag in ('insert', 'replace'):
+                for c in brevs[blo:bhi]:
+                    ui.write('+%s\n' % c, label='diff.inserted')
+            if tag == 'equal':
+                for c in arevs[alo:ahi]:
+                    ui.write(' %s\n' % c)
+        return 1
+
     func = revset.makematcher(tree)
     revs = func(repo)
     if ui.verbose:

tests/test-completion.t

@@ -269,7 +269,7 b' Show all commands + options'
   debugrebuildfncache: 
   debugrename: rev
   debugrevlog: changelog, manifest, dir, dump
-  debugrevspec: optimize, show-stage, no-optimized
+  debugrevspec: optimize, show-stage, no-optimized, verify-optimized
   debugsetparents: 
   debugsub: rev
   debugsuccessorssets: 

tests/test-revset.t

@@ -554,6 +554,37 b' parsed tree at stages:'
   abort: cannot use --optimize with --show-stage
   [255]
 
+verify optimized tree:
+
+  $ hg debugrevspec --verify '0|1'
+
+  $ hg debugrevspec --verify -v -p analyzed -p optimized 'r3232() & 2'
+  * analyzed:
+  (and
+    (func
+      ('symbol', 'r3232')
+      None)
+    ('symbol', '2'))
+  * optimized:
+  (and
+    ('symbol', '2')
+    (func
+      ('symbol', 'r3232')
+      None))
+  * analyzed set:
+  <baseset [2]>
+  * optimized set:
+  <baseset [2, 2]>
+  --- analyzed
+  +++ optimized
+   2
+  +2
+  [1]
+
+  $ hg debugrevspec --no-optimized --verify-optimized '0'
+  abort: cannot use --verify-optimized with --no-optimized
+  [255]
+
 Test that symbols only get parsed as functions if there's an opening
 parenthesis.